#peerreview — Public Fediverse posts
Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #peerreview, aggregated by home.social.
-
"In retrospect, these strategies were a form of authorial self-preservation."
Autoethnography of the rhetorical and emotional dimensions of writing about study limitations:
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/17470161251363704The paper draws on 8 manuscripts, 17 drafts, 22 #PeerReview by the author, journal entries, and email exchanges.
Interesting reflections & it illustrates the challenges and questions, especially if one has not written many manuscripts, yet.
-
"In retrospect, these strategies were a form of authorial self-preservation."
Autoethnography of the rhetorical and emotional dimensions of writing about study limitations:
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/17470161251363704The paper draws on 8 manuscripts, 17 drafts, 22 #PeerReview by the author, journal entries, and email exchanges.
Interesting reflections & it illustrates the challenges and questions, especially if one has not written many manuscripts, yet.
-
"In retrospect, these strategies were a form of authorial self-preservation."
Autoethnography of the rhetorical and emotional dimensions of writing about study limitations:
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/17470161251363704The paper draws on 8 manuscripts, 17 drafts, 22 #PeerReview by the author, journal entries, and email exchanges.
Interesting reflections & it illustrates the challenges and questions, especially if one has not written many manuscripts, yet.
-
Real peer review has never been tried
worksinprogress.co/issue/real-p... #science #sciencesky #philosophySky #PeerReview
Real peer review has never bee... -
Real peer review has never been tried
worksinprogress.co/issue/real-p... #science #sciencesky #philosophySky #PeerReview
Real peer review has never bee... -
Real peer review has never been tried
worksinprogress.co/issue/real-p... #science #sciencesky #philosophySky #PeerReview
Real peer review has never bee... -
Real peer review has never been tried
worksinprogress.co/issue/real-p... #science #sciencesky #philosophySky #PeerReview
Real peer review has never bee... -
Real peer review has never been tried
worksinprogress.co/issue/real-p... #science #sciencesky #philosophySky #PeerReview
Real peer review has never bee... -
"Peer review is imperfect, sometimes exclusionary, occasionally petty. We have all seen nonsensical reports and capricious delays. But the answer to those failings is to invest more in the human practice – through training, recognition and realistic expectation – not to hollow it out."
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review -
"Peer review is imperfect, sometimes exclusionary, occasionally petty. We have all seen nonsensical reports and capricious delays. But the answer to those failings is to invest more in the human practice – through training, recognition and realistic expectation – not to hollow it out."
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review -
"Peer review is imperfect, sometimes exclusionary, occasionally petty. We have all seen nonsensical reports and capricious delays. But the answer to those failings is to invest more in the human practice – through training, recognition and realistic expectation – not to hollow it out."
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783
#Academia #Assessment #PeerReview #ScholComm #Universities
Judges matter more than papers... -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783
#Academia #Assessment #PeerReview #ScholComm #Universities
Judges matter more than papers... -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783 -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783 -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783 -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783 -
New study: "We show…that research assessment is driven more by differences between evaluators than by difference in the evaluated research."
https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.09783 -
Will making ‘replication studies’ easier to find help science self-correct?
Credit: bpawesome/Getty The replication of experimental results is important for building credible science, but replication studies are often…
#NewsBeep #News #Science #Databases #GB #HumanitiesandSocialSciences #multidisciplinary #Peerreview #Researchdata #UK #UnitedKingdom
https://www.newsbeep.com/uk/697549/ -
Symbolic image of the state of #academic #publishing: The original study does not contain much detail (most certainly not a single word of #humour), and the #replication study is locked up behind a #paywall, on which #impactfactor, #peerreview, #plagiarism, #copyright and #publicationbias are having #popcorn.
-
Symbolic image of the state of #academic #publishing: The original study does not contain much detail (most certainly not a single word of #humour), and the #replication study is locked up behind a #paywall, on which #impactfactor, #peerreview, #plagiarism, #copyright and #publicationbias are having #popcorn.
-
Symbolic image of the state of #academic #publishing: The original study does not contain much detail (most certainly not a single word of #humour), and the #replication study is locked up behind a #paywall, on which #impactfactor, #peerreview, #plagiarism, #copyright and #publicationbias are having #popcorn.
-
Symbolic image of the state of #academic #publishing: The original study does not contain much detail (most certainly not a single word of #humour), and the #replication study is locked up behind a #paywall, on which #impactfactor, #peerreview, #plagiarism, #copyright and #publicationbias are having #popcorn.
-
Symbolic image of the state of #academic #publishing: The original study does not contain much detail (most certainly not a single word of #humour), and the #replication study is locked up behind a #paywall, on which #impactfactor, #peerreview, #plagiarism, #copyright and #publicationbias are having #popcorn.
-
"If we still believe that science is a vocation grounded in argument, curiosity and care, we can’t delegate judgement to machines"
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review
-
"If we still believe that science is a vocation grounded in argument, curiosity and care, we can’t delegate judgement to machines"
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review
-
"If we still believe that science is a vocation grounded in argument, curiosity and care, we can’t delegate judgement to machines"
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/ai-not-peer-so-it-cant-do-peer-review
-
If you coordinate a PREreview Club, we’ve got news for you
Now club leads can ask us to attach a review to their club’s page directly within the review workflow. No need to email us!
👉 Find out more about this and other platform optimizations for clubs in today’s Weeknote:
https://content.prereview.org/prereview-platform-news-17-july-2026/ -
If you coordinate a PREreview Club, we’ve got news for you
Now club leads can ask us to attach a review to their club’s page directly within the review workflow. No need to email us!
👉 Find out more about this and other platform optimizations for clubs in today’s Weeknote:
https://content.prereview.org/prereview-platform-news-17-july-2026/ -
If you coordinate a PREreview Club, we’ve got news for you
Now club leads can ask us to attach a review to their club’s page directly within the review workflow. No need to email us!
👉 Find out more about this and other platform optimizations for clubs in today’s Weeknote:
https://content.prereview.org/prereview-platform-news-17-july-2026/ -
If you coordinate a PREreview Club, we’ve got news for you
Now club leads can ask us to attach a review to their club’s page directly within the review workflow. No need to email us!
👉 Find out more about this and other platform optimizations for clubs in today’s Weeknote:
https://content.prereview.org/prereview-platform-news-17-july-2026/ -
If you coordinate a PREreview Club, we’ve got news for you
Now club leads can ask us to attach a review to their club’s page directly within the review workflow. No need to email us!
👉 Find out more about this and other platform optimizations for clubs in today’s Weeknote:
https://content.prereview.org/prereview-platform-news-17-july-2026/ -
Wut? Senior author Jonathan Grant writes about grant funding (Grant funding?) 😂
"The costs and benefits of research grant funding peer review" -
Wut? Senior author Jonathan Grant writes about grant funding (Grant funding?) 😂
"The costs and benefits of research grant funding peer review" -
Wut? Senior author Jonathan Grant writes about grant funding (Grant funding?) 😂
"The costs and benefits of research grant funding peer review" -
#NotNews24 | #UnbreaklingFuckITFridayNotNews; #IT's #DefinitelyNotNews and #SomeWeather...
#IT's #Still #JollySunny in #TheOutside; there will be #MoreSalad... 🥗 And, #FishCakes; they're a #TypeOfCake... #MadeWithFish...
#OrLobster... 🦞 | #WaitroseYutaniCorpsCooperative - we're #SomewhatMilitary and #HighlyWeaponised...
#CaptainRedBeanBear [ #FictionalCommunityManager] has #MadeSome... #Gazpacho...
#MescalineNotIncluded | #OtherSecondGenerationAntiPsychotics #AreAvailable
#TopTip: #OnlyForProfessionals...
#You can #AlwaysUse #AnotherGPTChatBot to #Diagnose a #PracticalTherapy for #YourMentalHealth #MentalDisorder; #IT should be #UsedInConjunction with #MedicalProfessionals #Subject to #PeerReview; #Because...
#That's #HowScienceWorks...
Have #AnotherPrideMonth; #OrSomething...
🧙⚔️🤖:wolfparty:🤖⚔️🧙 | :fediverse:🦹:PirateBadge:🦄:PirateBadge:🦹:fediverse:
#EuropeanServer #BeingEuropean #SomewhereInEurope #MFFS #LemonUp #FunTimeFridays #HappyBaconSammidgeDay #TheWeekend #Soon #TheWeekendAgain #AgainAgain #LittleMissPorkMarkets #FullMentalJacket #RedBeanBear #StillRed
-
It is 2026, and we still get this criticism in a review: "First and foremost, the contribution is primarily confirmatory […] I would argue that the work is predominantly incremental." Yes. This is called the scientific method. How can we change the strange interpretation of novelty that is in many reviewers' heads?
@seresearchers
#peerreview #EmpiricalResearch -
It is 2026, and we still get this criticism in a review: "First and foremost, the contribution is primarily confirmatory […] I would argue that the work is predominantly incremental." Yes. This is called the scientific method. How can we change the strange interpretation of novelty that is in many reviewers' heads?
@seresearchers
#peerreview #EmpiricalResearch -
It is 2026, and we still get this criticism in a review: "First and foremost, the contribution is primarily confirmatory […] I would argue that the work is predominantly incremental." Yes. This is called the scientific method. How can we change the strange interpretation of novelty that is in many reviewers' heads?
@seresearchers
#peerreview #EmpiricalResearch -
The review resulting from our Community #LiveReview on June 25th is now published.
When an important piece of research shared as a preprint on medRxiv was prevented from receiving journal-organized #PeerReview, the community joined forces and stepped in.
Open, community-driven review offers a different future for research evaluation—one centered on dialogue, transparency, training, and broader participation. A future that extends beyond the research publication as a finish line, to enable continuous scrutiny and conversation.
We are grateful to @csmarcum for taking the lead on this initiative, and to everyone who participated in this rigorous and deeply human collaborative review session.
👉 Read the review and share your thoughts openly through our comment feature: https://prereview.org/reviews/21327744
-
The review resulting from our Community #LiveReview on June 25th is now published.
When an important piece of research shared as a preprint on medRxiv was prevented from receiving journal-organized #PeerReview, the community joined forces and stepped in.
Open, community-driven review offers a different future for research evaluation—one centered on dialogue, transparency, training, and broader participation. A future that extends beyond the research publication as a finish line, to enable continuous scrutiny and conversation.
We are grateful to @csmarcum for taking the lead on this initiative, and to everyone who participated in this rigorous and deeply human collaborative review session.
👉 Read the review and share your thoughts openly through our comment feature: https://prereview.org/reviews/21327744
-
The review resulting from our Community #LiveReview on June 25th is now published.
When an important piece of research shared as a preprint on medRxiv was prevented from receiving journal-organized #PeerReview, the community joined forces and stepped in.
Open, community-driven review offers a different future for research evaluation—one centered on dialogue, transparency, training, and broader participation. A future that extends beyond the research publication as a finish line, to enable continuous scrutiny and conversation.
We are grateful to @csmarcum for taking the lead on this initiative, and to everyone who participated in this rigorous and deeply human collaborative review session.
👉 Read the review and share your thoughts openly through our comment feature: https://prereview.org/reviews/21327744
-
Oh, sweet summer child, you thought your preprint would magically appear on arXiv overnight? 😂 Apparently, someone finally decided to hold your self-important drivel to the same standards as actual academic work. 🧐 Maybe try peer review for once, champ! 🏆
https://fi-le.net/arxiv/ #preprintissues #peerreview #academicstandards #summerchild #selfimportance #HackerNews #ngated -
Oh, sweet summer child, you thought your preprint would magically appear on arXiv overnight? 😂 Apparently, someone finally decided to hold your self-important drivel to the same standards as actual academic work. 🧐 Maybe try peer review for once, champ! 🏆
https://fi-le.net/arxiv/ #preprintissues #peerreview #academicstandards #summerchild #selfimportance #HackerNews #ngated -
Oh, sweet summer child, you thought your preprint would magically appear on arXiv overnight? 😂 Apparently, someone finally decided to hold your self-important drivel to the same standards as actual academic work. 🧐 Maybe try peer review for once, champ! 🏆
https://fi-le.net/arxiv/ #preprintissues #peerreview #academicstandards #summerchild #selfimportance #HackerNews #ngated -
Want to always win research grants 🏆 and get all your manuscripts accepted? Scientists may have figured out what you need to tell #ChatGPT 🤖
A new study tested hidden prompt injections embedded in manuscripts. When reviewers uploaded the papers to public #LLMs and asked for a review, the hidden instructions could steer the model toward a positive evaluation with a ~99% success rate.
:doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05695-x
#GenAI #PeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PromptInjection #AcademicPublishing
-
Want to always win research grants 🏆 and get all your manuscripts accepted? Scientists may have figured out what you need to tell #ChatGPT 🤖
A new study tested hidden prompt injections embedded in manuscripts. When reviewers uploaded the papers to public #LLMs and asked for a review, the hidden instructions could steer the model toward a positive evaluation with a ~99% success rate.
:doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05695-x
#GenAI #PeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PromptInjection #AcademicPublishing
-
Want to always win research grants 🏆 and get all your manuscripts accepted? Scientists may have figured out what you need to tell #ChatGPT 🤖
A new study tested hidden prompt injections embedded in manuscripts. When reviewers uploaded the papers to public #LLMs and asked for a review, the hidden instructions could steer the model toward a positive evaluation with a ~99% success rate.
:doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05695-x
#GenAI #PeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PromptInjection #AcademicPublishing
-
Want to always win research grants 🏆 and get all your manuscripts accepted? Scientists may have figured out what you need to tell #ChatGPT 🤖
A new study tested hidden prompt injections embedded in manuscripts. When reviewers uploaded the papers to public #LLMs and asked for a review, the hidden instructions could steer the model toward a positive evaluation with a ~99% success rate.
:doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05695-x
#GenAI #PeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PromptInjection #AcademicPublishing
-
Want to always win research grants 🏆 and get all your manuscripts accepted? Scientists may have figured out what you need to tell #ChatGPT 🤖
A new study tested hidden prompt injections embedded in manuscripts. When reviewers uploaded the papers to public #LLMs and asked for a review, the hidden instructions could steer the model toward a positive evaluation with a ~99% success rate.
:doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-026-05695-x
#GenAI #PeerReview #ResearchIntegrity #PromptInjection #AcademicPublishing