Review: Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 2 – Their Attempt at Game of Thrones
Continuing with our review of Rings of Power Season 3, it seems that the showrunners are desperately trying a new angle with episode 2. In episode 2, most of the screen time is spent on the Numenor plotline, and as we try to remember what happened in Numenor last season (not that it really matters with the 5-year time jump), the showrunners are trying to add some intrigue. Where in Season 2 they were trying to make Sauron seem like Walter White and Tony Soprano, in this season, they are trying to make the Numenor subplot feel like Game of Thrones. As though they weren’t already setting themselves up for failure there, we’re also getting the orc with the arc and a Chosen-One character who is evil. Let’s hop in.
Starting with the Numenor plot line, back in Season 2, Ar-Pharazon plotted to overthrow Miriel in a coup and planned to overthrow those faithful to her and the Valar. He was successful, was crowned king of Numenor, and the persecution began. Meanwhile, Miriel gives Elendil Narsil and sends him away for his own safety, while Isildur (who got left in Middle Earth in Season 1) sails back to Numenor. Meanwhile, Ar-Pharazon’s son, Kemen, is in Middle Earth, running Pelargir, Numenor’s port town.
If you forgot all of that from Season 2, I don’t blame you. I had to Google most of that.
With all of that setup, we now fast-forward 5 years and see that Ar-Pharazon is doing pretty well as king. He’s quite popular, and frankly, seems to be a better ruler than Miriel was in Season 1 judging by the people’s response to his procession. However, that is not to last long as Isildur, who is working with the Faithful, tries to assassinate him, fails, and his partner in crime is taken hostage.
It’s pretty bad when a show makes a character who is a straight up villain in the source text look like a good ruler, but moving along…
After the assassination attempt, Ar-Pharazon and some of his right-hand men get together to discuss who might have been behind the attempt. They suspect that there’s a spy in their midst who leaked the Ar-Pharazon’s procession route, allowing someone to block their path and putting Ar-Pharazon in the prime spot to be shot. This is where the show starts trying to make itself feel like Game of Thrones with political intrigue as the characters try to find out who is on their side and who isn’t, but it fails spectacularly. Not only do some of their suspicions feel stupid (such as the one about the supposed leak), but the character who we find out is a spy, Earien, is an idiot. She gives herself away easily and her position in Ar-Pharazon’s court as his best interrogator feels out of place for her character.
Had the writers been smarter and written her better, she could have been an interesting character. She could have been a sort of femme-fatal double agent whose story spans the entire season. She could have had a full character arc, and the Numenor plot could maybe have been improved, but as it is, she sucks, and due to incompetent writing, kills herself at the end of the episode by jumping off a balcony.
I believe the scene where she jumps is supposed to be a visualization of how the audience retention rate will drop dramatically after episode four if Amazon is lucky.
But moving on from the Numenor plotline, we have to check in with our buddies over in Khazad-Dum. Back in episode one, Durin and Thrain get in a fight, tumble off a tiny wall, and land at the feet of our favorite orc with an arc, Marnukh. They apparently decide to take it hostage, and, after a drawn out conversation about what to do with it, decide to hand it over to Elrond to take to Galadriel.
Once again, how Elrond is so casually traveling between Rivendell and Khazad-Dum when that area is run by Sauron is beyond me.
Elrond agrees to take Marnukh to Galadriel since Marnukh swears he has information that could save Middle Earth, even though both Elrond and the Dwarves are aware it could be a trap. With the orc now off their hands, the dwarves seem to chill for the rest of the episode until they get some visitors from Spirit Halloween: the Temu Nazgul. For some reason, the Temu Nazgul are admitted into Khazad-Dum, and begin trying to peddle the magic rings to Durin. (“Have you heard of our Lord and Savior, Sauron – sorry – Annatar, Lord of Gifts?”) Durin has the appropriate reaction of “How the heck did you get in my house? Get out!” and is initially backed by Thrain, but towards the end of the episode, Thrain goes to the Temu Nazgul for more information on those nice, shiny, cursed rings.
Who thought this was a good storyline, I don’t know.
After that, however, we get what may be one of the worst plotlines in the show: the angsty chosen one. Back in Season 1, we had the misfortune of being introduced to Theo, a fatherless, angsty teen who is as likeable as phlegm. He has no personality other than angst and happens to have a cursed sword that is also the key to a Rube Goldberg machine designed to make a volcano explode. Then, in Season 2, Theo has fled to Pelargir after his home gets turned into Mordor, and for no reason, becomes the Lord of Pelargir until the Numenorians take it over. But, now, he’s received an upgrade, that upgrade being that he’s 5 years older, and is no longer angsty, just evil. He finds out about the magic ring situation, goes to Mordor with some other people, and is almost killed in the fight over a ring. However, Sauron helps him out because he noticed a scar on his wrist that matched the pommel of the cursed sword-key thing and offers to show Theo his father.
Now, Theo has already established that his father is dead, so usually being asked if you would like to meet your dead father is taken as a threat. But, Theo isn’t just angsty to the point of being evil – he’s also supremely stupid. So, he takes Sauron up on the offer, and Sauron does some necromancy and chats with Theo’s father who can only speak in Black Speech. After translating, Sauron explains that Theo’s father was of a noble line who may have been connected to Morgoth. Thus, Theo is somehow entitled to power and becomes the show’s evil chosen one figure.
Once again, whoever thought this was a good storyline should be fired. Theo has done absolutely nothing to warrant this storyline, and it feels very contrived.
Until next time,
M.J.
#Amazon #Blog #Fantasy #LordOfTheRings #LOTR #movies #OpinionPeice #Review #RingsOfPower #TVReview #Tolkien #TV #Writing