#argumentation — Public Fediverse posts

🎧 Neue Podcastfolge online!

Fördert computerbasiertes Lernen die Argumentationsfähigkeiten und den Wissenserwerb von SchülerInnen?

In unserer neuen Folge von Forschung fördert Bildung könnt ihr nun das Hörerlebnis zu unserem Kurzreview 9 anhören! 🎙️

🎙️ Jetzt auf den gängigen Podcast-Plattformen!
#Podcast #Bildung #DigitalesLernen #Argumentation #Wissenserwerb #MINT #CHU #ForschungfördertBildung

#Fakten in Zeiten von #KI... Heute morgen im Zug unterhalten sich zwei junge Menschen über den Begriff der "selbstfahrenden Arbeitsmaschine". Der eine bezeichnet seine Maschine als selbstfahrend, der andere verneint. Wie einigen sich die beiden in ihrer #Argumentation ?
Der eine nutzt Papier und Autorität: "ich bringe es dir morgen schriftlich von meinem Teamleiter mit" - das lässt sein Gegenüber kurz verstummen und zum Handy greifen: "Chatgpt sagt XY ist keine selbstfahrende Arbeitsmaschine" -

@AwetTesfaiesus
Leider sind aktuell -auch in Deutschland- Spitzenpolitiker eher auf mediale Wirkung, also das Erreichen maximaler Aufmerksamkeit in Sekundenbruchteilen aus, als auf argumentativen Wettstreit, der Lösungen erreichbar und den Menschen verständlich machen könnte.

Dominante Worte ohne Abwägung oder Verstehen der #Argumente Andersdenkender, ist #Populismus.

Wenn #Argumentation und #Dialog nicht mehr zählen, hilft auch beste #Schulbildung und Lernen von #Erörterungen nix mehr ... 😦

@AwetTesfaiesus
Leider sind aktuell -auch in Deutschland- Spitzenpolitiker eher auf mediale Wirkung, also das Erreichen maximaler Aufmerksamkeit in Sekundenbruchteilen aus, als auf argumentativen Wettstreit, der Lösungen erreichbar und den Menschen verständlich machen könnte.

Dominante Worte ohne Abwägung oder Verstehen der #Argumente Andersdenkender, ist #Populismus.

Wenn #Argumentation und #Dialog nicht mehr zählen, hilft auch beste #Schulbildung und Lernen von #Erörterungen nix mehr ... 😦

@AwetTesfaiesus
Leider sind aktuell -auch in Deutschland- Spitzenpolitiker eher auf mediale Wirkung, also das Erreichen maximaler Aufmerksamkeit in Sekundenbruchteilen aus, als auf argumentativen Wettstreit, der Lösungen erreichbar und den Menschen verständlich machen könnte.

Dominante Worte ohne Abwägung oder Verstehen der #Argumente Andersdenkender, ist #Populismus.

Wenn #Argumentation und #Dialog nicht mehr zählen, hilft auch beste #Schulbildung und Lernen von #Erörterungen nix mehr ... 😦

@AwetTesfaiesus
Leider sind aktuell -auch in Deutschland- Spitzenpolitiker eher auf mediale Wirkung, also das Erreichen maximaler Aufmerksamkeit in Sekundenbruchteilen aus, als auf argumentativen Wettstreit, der Lösungen erreichbar und den Menschen verständlich machen könnte.

Dominante Worte ohne Abwägung oder Verstehen der #Argumente Andersdenkender, ist #Populismus.

Wenn #Argumentation und #Dialog nicht mehr zählen, hilft auch beste #Schulbildung und Lernen von #Erörterungen nix mehr ... 😦

@AwetTesfaiesus
Leider sind aktuell -auch in Deutschland- Spitzenpolitiker eher auf mediale Wirkung, also das Erreichen maximaler Aufmerksamkeit in Sekundenbruchteilen aus, als auf argumentativen Wettstreit, der Lösungen erreichbar und den Menschen verständlich machen könnte.

Dominante Worte ohne Abwägung oder Verstehen der #Argumente Andersdenkender, ist #Populismus.

Wenn #Argumentation und #Dialog nicht mehr zählen, hilft auch beste #Schulbildung und Lernen von #Erörterungen nix mehr ... 😦

@Jeanneadebats C dé chifre 2 l'extrem gauchiasse ki manipul lé merdias é lé jug rouge

#lavéritévraie #argumentation #sarcasme

@Jeanneadebats C dé chifre 2 l'extrem gauchiasse ki manipul lé merdias é lé jug rouge

#lavéritévraie #argumentation #sarcasme

@Jeanneadebats C dé chifre 2 l'extrem gauchiasse ki manipul lé merdias é lé jug rouge

#lavéritévraie #argumentation #sarcasme

Informaalisen logiikan uranuurtajiin kuuluvan Trudy Govierin uusi koostekirja ilimaatteks saavavilla, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/454

Kirjoittajan julkaisuja PhilPapersissa, https://philpeople.org/profiles/trudy-rose-govier

#informalLogic #logic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #thinking #criticalThinking #openAccess #epistemology #philosophy #paattely #argumentointi #filosofia #kirja #govier #wsia

Informaalisen logiikan uranuurtajiin kuuluvan Trudy Govierin uusi koostekirja ilimaatteks saavavilla, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/454

Kirjoittajan julkaisuja PhilPapersissa, https://philpeople.org/profiles/trudy-rose-govier

#informalLogic #logic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #thinking #criticalThinking #openAccess #epistemology #philosophy #paattely #argumentointi #filosofia #kirja #govier #wsia

Informaalisen logiikan uranuurtajiin kuuluvan Trudy Govierin uusi koostekirja ilimaatteks saavavilla, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/454

Kirjoittajan julkaisuja PhilPapersissa, https://philpeople.org/profiles/trudy-rose-govier

#informalLogic #logic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #thinking #criticalThinking #openAccess #epistemology #philosophy #paattely #argumentointi #filosofia #kirja #govier #wsia

Informaalisen logiikan uranuurtajiin kuuluvan Trudy Govierin uusi koostekirja ilimaatteks saavavilla, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/454

Kirjoittajan julkaisuja PhilPapersissa, https://philpeople.org/profiles/trudy-rose-govier

#informalLogic #logic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #thinking #criticalThinking #openAccess #epistemology #philosophy #paattely #argumentointi #filosofia #kirja #govier #wsia

If your objection to something is just “it's biased”, then you do not yet have an objection.

I mention #theBiasFallacy in "Strategic Reflectivism":
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.22987

and explain it on my #blog: https://byrdnick.com/archives/11072/the-bias-fallacy

#logic #argumentation #debate #edu #criticalThinking

If your objection to something is just “it's biased”, then you do not yet have an objection.

I mention #theBiasFallacy in "Strategic Reflectivism":
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.22987

and explain it on my #blog: https://byrdnick.com/archives/11072/the-bias-fallacy

#logic #argumentation #debate #edu #criticalThinking

If your objection to something is just “it's biased”, then you do not yet have an objection.

I mention #theBiasFallacy in "Strategic Reflectivism":
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.22987

and explain it on my #blog: https://byrdnick.com/archives/11072/the-bias-fallacy

#logic #argumentation #debate #edu #criticalThinking

If your objection to something is just “it's biased”, then you do not yet have an objection.

I mention #theBiasFallacy in "Strategic Reflectivism":
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.22987

and explain it on my #blog: https://byrdnick.com/archives/11072/the-bias-fallacy

#logic #argumentation #debate #edu #criticalThinking

If your objection to something is just “it's biased”, then you do not yet have an objection.

I mention #theBiasFallacy in "Strategic Reflectivism":
https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2505.22987

and explain it on my #blog: https://byrdnick.com/archives/11072/the-bias-fallacy

#logic #argumentation #debate #edu #criticalThinking

Leo Groarke has revised his SEP-entry on Informal Logic, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/

The 2019 WSIA-volume on Informal Logic mentioned at the introduction is a nice additional resource, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/123, and the Journal Informal Logic offers a glimpse of some current discussions, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Groarke's entry provides a list of OIR's, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/#Oth, including to the hilarious Arguer's Lexicon, https://web.colby.edu/arguerslexicon/, and some entries in the Bibliography are available online.

#logic #informalLogic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #epistemology #tietoteoria #philosophy #filosofia #ajattelu #thinking #science #rhetoric #abduction #sep #pseudoScience

Leo Groarke has revised his SEP-entry on Informal Logic, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/

The 2019 WSIA-volume on Informal Logic mentioned at the introduction is a nice additional resource, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/123, and the Journal Informal Logic offers a glimpse of some current discussions, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Groarke's entry provides a list of OIR's, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/#Oth, including to the hilarious Arguer's Lexicon, https://web.colby.edu/arguerslexicon/, and some entries in the Bibliography are available online.

#logic #informalLogic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #epistemology #tietoteoria #philosophy #filosofia #ajattelu #thinking #science #rhetoric #abduction #sep #pseudoScience

Leo Groarke has revised his SEP-entry on Informal Logic, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/

The 2019 WSIA-volume on Informal Logic mentioned at the introduction is a nice additional resource, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/123, and the Journal Informal Logic offers a glimpse of some current discussions, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Groarke's entry provides a list of OIR's, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/#Oth, including to the hilarious Arguer's Lexicon, https://web.colby.edu/arguerslexicon/, and some entries in the Bibliography are available online.

#logic #informalLogic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #epistemology #tietoteoria #philosophy #filosofia #ajattelu #thinking #science #rhetoric #abduction #sep #pseudoScience

Leo Groarke has revised his SEP-entry on Informal Logic, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/

The 2019 WSIA-volume on Informal Logic mentioned at the introduction is a nice additional resource, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/123, and the Journal Informal Logic offers a glimpse of some current discussions, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Groarke's entry provides a list of OIR's, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/#Oth, including to the hilarious Arguer's Lexicon, https://web.colby.edu/arguerslexicon/, and some entries in the Bibliography are available online.

#logic #informalLogic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #epistemology #tietoteoria #philosophy #filosofia #ajattelu #thinking #science #rhetoric #abduction #sep #pseudoScience

Leo Groarke has revised his SEP-entry on Informal Logic, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/

The 2019 WSIA-volume on Informal Logic mentioned at the introduction is a nice additional resource, https://windsor.scholarsportal.info/omp/index.php/wsia/catalog/book/123, and the Journal Informal Logic offers a glimpse of some current discussions, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Groarke's entry provides a list of OIR's, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-informal/#Oth, including to the hilarious Arguer's Lexicon, https://web.colby.edu/arguerslexicon/, and some entries in the Bibliography are available online.

#logic #informalLogic #argument #argumentation #reasoning #epistemology #tietoteoria #philosophy #filosofia #ajattelu #thinking #science #rhetoric #abduction #sep #pseudoScience

https://argumentation.online/ Was für eine coole Sammlung auf dieser Internetseite!
#FediLZ #schule #FediCampus #PhiloEdu #Argumentation #Didaktik

https://argumentation.online/ Was für eine coole Sammlung auf dieser Internetseite!
#FediLZ #schule #FediCampus #PhiloEdu #Argumentation #Didaktik

Informal Logicin numero 4/2025 näkyy ilmestyneen Joulun alla, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisällysluettelosta selviää, mitä olisi tarjolla, ja abstrakteista saa lisävihiä. Tiededenialistiseen nyky-populismiin saattaisi osua visuimmin Gustavo Picazon pohdinta hevonpaska-argumentoinnin taksonomian kehittelystä, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/8117?

#logic #informalLogic #epistemology #bullshit #science #reasoning #argumentation #evaluation #tiede #filosofia #philosophy #journal #denialism

Informal Logicin numero 4/2025 näkyy ilmestyneen Joulun alla, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisällysluettelosta selviää, mitä olisi tarjolla, ja abstrakteista saa lisävihiä. Tiededenialistiseen nyky-populismiin saattaisi osua visuimmin Gustavo Picazon pohdinta hevonpaska-argumentoinnin taksonomian kehittelystä, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/8117?

#logic #informalLogic #epistemology #bullshit #science #reasoning #argumentation #evaluation #tiede #filosofia #philosophy #journal #denialism

Informal Logicin numero 4/2025 näkyy ilmestyneen Joulun alla, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisällysluettelosta selviää, mitä olisi tarjolla, ja abstrakteista saa lisävihiä. Tiededenialistiseen nyky-populismiin saattaisi osua visuimmin Gustavo Picazon pohdinta hevonpaska-argumentoinnin taksonomian kehittelystä, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/8117?

#logic #informalLogic #epistemology #bullshit #science #reasoning #argumentation #evaluation #tiede #filosofia #philosophy #journal #denialism

Informal Logicin numero 4/2025 näkyy ilmestyneen Joulun alla, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisällysluettelosta selviää, mitä olisi tarjolla, ja abstrakteista saa lisävihiä. Tiededenialistiseen nyky-populismiin saattaisi osua visuimmin Gustavo Picazon pohdinta hevonpaska-argumentoinnin taksonomian kehittelystä, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/8117?

#logic #informalLogic #epistemology #bullshit #science #reasoning #argumentation #evaluation #tiede #filosofia #philosophy #journal #denialism

Very glad that our research proposal 'Replicating a Classic Study on Argument Quantity and Quality' was funded by the NWO replication studies programme. List of all funded projects: https://www.openscience.nl/en/news/27-studies-re-examined #argumentation #persuasion #research

📢 Unsere Kollegin Viktorija Völker spricht auf der 5th European Conference on Argumentation, die vom 23.–26. Sept. in Warschau stattfindet, über #KI und unser Verständnis von Fehlschlüssen.

In ihrem Vortrag zeigt sie: Generative KI „begründet“ nicht, sie prognostiziert – und wirkt dennoch überzeugend. Daraus entstehen „algorithmische Fehlschlüsse“: Fehler nicht in der Maschine, sondern in unserem Vertrauen in ihre Outputs.

👉 Mehr Infos: https://ecargument.org/

#ECA2025 #AI #Argumentation

Analysis of over 6.500 comment replies on social media identified seven different types of counters to objectionable comments. Though *ad hominem* attacks made up more than 40% of the replies, the prosocial tactics of moral corruption and logical disqualification together made up the second largest group of replies.

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0328550

#Science #SocialScience #Argumentation #SocialMedia

@WirWolfgang

Typische #Argumentation von #VölkerMördern, die permanent von eigenen #Verbrechen ablenken wollen.

Typisch auch der Webserver-Standort:
Hostname steady.page Internetdienstanbieter CLOUDFLARENET

When debating, if GPT-4 has access to its opponent's basic demographic data, it is markedly more persuasive than when it does not, and also more so than a human debater with or without the demographic information.

Summary: https://www.psypost.org/scientists-demonstrate-that-ais-superhuman-persuasiveness-is-already-a-reality/

Original paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-025-02194-6

#Argumentation #Debate #Psychology #LLM

Appreciation of top-tier rhetoric | @destiny

#Debate #Rhetoric #Argumentation #Reasoning #Destiny

#ArgumentMapping is supposed to improve #argumentation, but argument map classes are often flipped (vs. lecture).

So is it #logic explanation or Socratic discussion that helps?

One experiment found that it's probably the latter.

https://doi.org/10.30191/ETS.202504_28(2).TP06

#edu #CriticalThinking

• Conversational back-and-forth is a terrible format for resolving disagreements in good faith.
• Bullet points are helpful for making disagreements productive.

Sarah Constantin, 2019, https://srconstantin.github.io/2019/09/16/bullet-points.html

#clarity #argumentation #arguing #arguments #discussion #consensus #teamWork #facilitation

• Conversational back-and-forth is a terrible format for resolving disagreements in good faith.
• Bullet points are helpful for making disagreements productive.

Sarah Constantin, 2019, https://srconstantin.github.io/2019/09/16/bullet-points.html

#clarity #argumentation #arguing #arguments #discussion #consensus #teamWork #facilitation

• Conversational back-and-forth is a terrible format for resolving disagreements in good faith.
• Bullet points are helpful for making disagreements productive.

Sarah Constantin, 2019, https://srconstantin.github.io/2019/09/16/bullet-points.html

#clarity #argumentation #arguing #arguments #discussion #consensus #teamWork #facilitation

• Conversational back-and-forth is a terrible format for resolving disagreements in good faith.
• Bullet points are helpful for making disagreements productive.

Sarah Constantin, 2019, https://srconstantin.github.io/2019/09/16/bullet-points.html

#clarity #argumentation #arguing #arguments #discussion #consensus #teamWork #facilitation

• Conversational back-and-forth is a terrible format for resolving disagreements in good faith.
• Bullet points are helpful for making disagreements productive.

Sarah Constantin, 2019, https://srconstantin.github.io/2019/09/16/bullet-points.html

#clarity #argumentation #arguing #arguments #discussion #consensus #teamWork #facilitation

Can #AI improve team-based #argumentation beyond the benefits of group work and #argumentMapping?

In a 6-week quasi-experiment with 67 Indonesian students, the AI-assisted group developed more well-rounded arguments and showed more "group efficacy".

https://doi.org/10.6706/TIESPJ.202412_15(2).0004 #edu

We invite applications for two fully funded #PhD positions in a project on "multimodal argumentation" (https://sites.google.com/rug.nl/multimodal/home) - especially interesting for applicants with an interest in #DiscourseAnalysis, #linguistics, and/or the #philosophy of #argumentation and #language.

For more info, see https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B82P and https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B83P

#job #Groningen #PhilosophyOfLanguage #ArgumentationTheory #GradSchool #SocialEpistemology #PhDPosition

We invite applications for two fully funded #PhD positions in a project on "multimodal argumentation" (https://sites.google.com/rug.nl/multimodal/home) - especially interesting for applicants with an interest in #DiscourseAnalysis, #linguistics, and/or the #philosophy of #argumentation and #language.

For more info, see https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B82P and https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B83P

#job #Groningen #PhilosophyOfLanguage #ArgumentationTheory #GradSchool #SocialEpistemology #PhDPosition

We invite applications for two fully funded #PhD positions in a project on "multimodal argumentation" (https://sites.google.com/rug.nl/multimodal/home) - especially interesting for applicants with an interest in #DiscourseAnalysis, #linguistics, and/or the #philosophy of #argumentation and #language.

For more info, see https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B82P and https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B83P

#job #Groningen #PhilosophyOfLanguage #ArgumentationTheory #GradSchool #SocialEpistemology #PhDPosition

We invite applications for two fully funded #PhD positions in a project on "multimodal argumentation" (https://sites.google.com/rug.nl/multimodal/home) - especially interesting for applicants with an interest in #DiscourseAnalysis, #linguistics, and/or the #philosophy of #argumentation and #language.

For more info, see https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B82P and https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B83P

#job #Groningen #PhilosophyOfLanguage #ArgumentationTheory #GradSchool #SocialEpistemology #PhDPosition

We invite applications for two fully funded #PhD positions in a project on "multimodal argumentation" (https://sites.google.com/rug.nl/multimodal/home) - especially interesting for applicants with an interest in #DiscourseAnalysis, #linguistics, and/or the #philosophy of #argumentation and #language.

For more info, see https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B82P and https://www.rug.nl/about-ug/work-with-us/job-opportunities/?details=00347-02S000B83P

#job #Groningen #PhilosophyOfLanguage #ArgumentationTheory #GradSchool #SocialEpistemology #PhDPosition

Uusi numero Informal Logic -journaalissa on ilmestynyt, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisältää mm. pohdintaa false dilemman virheellisyydestä, argumenttien hyveteoreettisesta arvioinnista, syvistä erimielisyyksistä, selitysten justifioivuudesta sekä jatkoa keskusteluun argumenteilla argumentoinnista.

Pois-pääteltynä muistetaan päättelyvirheiden ja fiktion logiikkaa tutkinutta ja tietoteorian matematisoinnista haaveillutta John Woodsia.

#informalLogic #argument #argumentation #logic #epistemology #filosofia #philosophy #new #falseDilemma #virtueEpistemology #disagreements #explanations #reasoning

Uusi numero Informal Logic -journaalissa on ilmestynyt, https://informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic

Sisältää mm. pohdintaa false dilemman virheellisyydestä, argumenttien hyveteoreettisesta arvioinnista, syvistä erimielisyyksistä, selitysten justifioivuudesta sekä jatkoa keskusteluun argumenteilla argumentoinnista.

Pois-pääteltynä muistetaan päättelyvirheiden ja fiktion logiikkaa tutkinutta ja tietoteorian matematisoinnista haaveillutta John Woodsia.

#informalLogic #argument #argumentation #logic #epistemology #filosofia #philosophy #new #falseDilemma #virtueEpistemology #disagreements #explanations #reasoning