April 3rd, 2012, began like any other day for Ken Jouppi, a longtime bush pilot in Alaska. He was scheduled to fly a passenger and her groceries from Fairbanks to the village of Beaver. Hidden in the passenger’s luggage, though, were two cases of Budweiser, along with four additional six-packs. They were intended as a gift to her husband, who worked in Beaver as the local postmaster.
The beer was illegal to bring to Beaver, which voted to prohibit alcohol in 2004. Before Ken could take off, state troopers searched the plane and discovered the beer. Ken insisted he did not know about the beer. The troopers thought differently. Ken was charged, convicted of a misdemeanor, and sentenced to the statutory minimum: a $1,500 fine and three days in jail.
But the State wasn’t done with him yet. For the past fourteen years, prosecutors have also been trying to forfeit Ken’s airplane, a Cessna U206D, worth about $95,000. For his part, Ken maintained that the forfeiture would violate the Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment. And in April 2025, the Alaska Supreme Court issued an extraordinary ruling. Starting from the premise that Ken must have known about a single six-pack of his passenger’s beer, the court ruled that forfeiting Ken’s airplane was not an excessive fine. “[T]he illegal importation of even a six-pack of beer causes grave societal harm,” the court reasoned, so forfeiting Ken’s plane “does not violate the Excessive Fines Clause.”
The end result: a $95,000 plane forfeited for a six-pack of Budweiser.
But Ken is not giving up the fight. Instead, he’s partnered with the Institute for Justice to ask the U.S. Supreme Court to step in and give much-needed clarity to what constitutes an unconstitutionally excessive fine. In an era where enforcement agencies (in the Supreme Court’s words) “increasingly depend heavily on fines and fees as a source of general revenue,” it’s critical that the Court invigorate the Bill of Rights’ Excessive Fines Clause in a way that better secures protections for ordinary people nationwide. In July 2026, the Supreme Court agreed to hear Ken’s case. The Court will hear oral argument over the winter of 2026–2027 and will likely issue a decision by July 2027.
#video #IJ