#peerreviewing — Public Fediverse posts
Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #peerreviewing, aggregated by home.social.
-
📰 La revue @Nature étend à tous les domaines scientifiques la possibilité de publier des #RegisteredReports (un modèle qui consiste à soumettre à l’#EvaluationParLesPairs 🧑🔬 🧪 un #ProtocoleDeRecherche avant que les données ne soient recueillies )
#IntégritéScientifique, #Transparence, #PeerReviewing -
In case you missed it, last November a vulnerability in OpenReview led to a #dataleak of 10,000 confidential submissions to the International Conference on Learning and Representation (ICLR).
Leaked data included detailed reviewer information and no-longer-anonymous reviews.
-
In case you missed it, last November a vulnerability in OpenReview led to a #dataleak of 10,000 confidential submissions to the International Conference on Learning and Representation (ICLR).
Leaked data included detailed reviewer information and no-longer-anonymous reviews.
-
The Guardian describes the process of getting #published in #science #journals as #broken: In 2020 alone, #academics globally spent >100 million hours #PeerReviewing journal papers. In the US, that time spent amounted to >$1.5 billion of free labor." https://www.theguardian.com/science/2025/jul/13/quality-of-scientific-papers-questioned-as-academics-overwhelmed-by-the-millions-published (1/2)
-
The Guardian describes the process of getting #published in #science #journals as #broken: In 2020 alone, #academics globally spent >100 million hours #PeerReviewing journal papers. In the US, that time spent amounted to >$1.5 billion of free labor." https://www.theguardian.com/science/2025/jul/13/quality-of-scientific-papers-questioned-as-academics-overwhelmed-by-the-millions-published (1/2)
-
Frontiers introduces FAIR² Data Management - Research Information
L'éditeur scientifique Fontiers lance le #peerreviewing par l'#AI #artificialintelligence avec son service FAIR² Data Management
https://www.researchinformation.info/news/frontiers-introduces-fair%C2%B2-data-management/ -
Deux des fondateurs de #PeerCommunityIn, Denis Bourguet et Thomas Guillemaud, plaident pour des décisions claires d’acceptation ou de rejet des #Préprints peer-reviewés car ⚠️ #PeerReviewing et Curation ne sont pas nécessairement des validations
➡️ https://www.coalition-s.org/blog/peer-reviewed-preprints-and-the-publish-review-curate-model/
-
Deux des fondateurs de #PeerCommunityIn, Denis Bourguet et Thomas Guillemaud, plaident pour des décisions claires d’acceptation ou de rejet des #Préprints peer-reviewés car ⚠️ #PeerReviewing et Curation ne sont pas nécessairement des validations
➡️ https://www.coalition-s.org/blog/peer-reviewed-preprints-and-the-publish-review-curate-model/
-
Deux des fondateurs de #PeerCommunityIn, Denis Bourguet et Thomas Guillemaud, plaident pour des décisions claires d’acceptation ou de rejet des #Préprints peer-reviewés car ⚠️ #PeerReviewing et Curation ne sont pas nécessairement des validations
➡️ https://www.coalition-s.org/blog/peer-reviewed-preprints-and-the-publish-review-curate-model/
-
Deux des fondateurs de #PeerCommunityIn, Denis Bourguet et Thomas Guillemaud, plaident pour des décisions claires d’acceptation ou de rejet des #Préprints peer-reviewés car ⚠️ #PeerReviewing et Curation ne sont pas nécessairement des validations
➡️ https://www.coalition-s.org/blog/peer-reviewed-preprints-and-the-publish-review-curate-model/
-
#Vanity Journals, Conflicts of Interest, and the Quest for #Research #Integrity
👉 "November 2024 has been another intriguing month for the forensic #scientometrics community. A particular gem of a sentence from a paper in the 'International Journal of Hydrogen Energy’ has been making the rounds on social media and PubPeer, prompting lively discussions."
https://fosci.substack.com/p/vanity-journals-conflicts-of-interest
#VanityJournals #journals #publishing #academicpublishing #ScholComm #ethics #Elsevier #science #peerreviewing
-
#Vanity Journals, Conflicts of Interest, and the Quest for #Research #Integrity
👉 "November 2024 has been another intriguing month for the forensic #scientometrics community. A particular gem of a sentence from a paper in the 'International Journal of Hydrogen Energy’ has been making the rounds on social media and PubPeer, prompting lively discussions."
https://fosci.substack.com/p/vanity-journals-conflicts-of-interest
#VanityJournals #journals #publishing #academicpublishing #ScholComm #ethics #Elsevier #science #peerreviewing
-
[Report] rapport MIT- NSF sur l' #openaccess côté #USA “Access to Science & Scholarship 2024: Building an Evidence Base to Support the Future of Open Research Policy” => https://mitpress.mit.edu/the-mit-press-releases-report-on-the-future-of-open-access-publishing-and-policy/
#openscience #impact #policies #science #peerreviewing #datasharing #infrastructures -
Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats: A Comprehensive SWOT Analysis of AI and Human Expertise in Peer Review - The Scholarly Kitchen
Réflexion sur l'interaction #peerreviewing #peerreviewer et #ai #artificialinteligence
https://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2024/09/12/strengths-weaknesses-opportunities-and-threats-a-comprehensive-swot-analysis-of-ai-and-human-expertise-in-peer-review/ -
Talking about #arXiv #bioRxiv, one weakness is that there is no "flag" to indicate whether PDF is a #preprint or the post- #peerReview #postprint. I am surprised at the lack of attention on this.
Although I have my reservations on the quality of #peerReviewing in general, I believe it should be a point of attention of an institutional archive to make sure the file is post-peer review, or, if that version is under paywall only (which is a problem), state it at least.
-
Talking about #arXiv #bioRxiv, one weakness is that there is no "flag" to indicate whether PDF is a #preprint or the post- #peerReview #postprint. I am surprised at the lack of attention on this.
Although I have my reservations on the quality of #peerReviewing in general, I believe it should be a point of attention of an institutional archive to make sure the file is post-peer review, or, if that version is under paywall only (which is a problem), state it at least.
-
“It is becoming increasingly difficult to find reviewers”—myths and facts about #peerreview
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00359-023-01642-w -
Prolific #autism researcher has two dozen papers retracted
👉 An autism researcher lost two dozen papers to #retraction 8 years after the publisher was made aware of potentially troubling editorial practices. #Elsevier cited undisclosed conflicts of interest, duplicated methodology and a “compromised” #peerreview process as reasons for the #retractions.
https://www.spectrumnews.org/news/prolific-autism-researcher-has-two-dozen-papers-retracted/
#peerreviewing #research #science #ethics #Publishing #selfcitation #metrics
-
[#Primo] Making the peer reviewed icon more accurate in #CentralDiscoveryIndex data
https://ideas.exlibrisgroup.com/forums/574345-content/suggestions/38315248-making-the-peer-reviewed-icon-more-accurate -
How to Review #Conference Proposals (and Why You Should Bother)
👉 This essay provides advice for effectively #reviewing conference proposals, including how to write comments that are helpful to proposal authors, and issues to consider when assigning proposal ratings and recommending acceptance or rejection.
-
New Blog Post Alert!
How do you work with Pull Requests in #AzureDevOps? I have written down how I use them in the development process of our #datawarehouse development using #DatabaseProjects. How Pull Requests allowed me to introduce #PeerReviewing into the development process.
Find out how to get started with #PullRequests in #AzureDevOps!
https://www.oliviervs.be/database-projects/database-projects-working-with-pull-requests/
-
New Blog Post Alert!
How do you work with Pull Requests in #AzureDevOps? I have written down how I use them in the development process of our #datawarehouse development using #DatabaseProjects. How Pull Requests allowed me to introduce #PeerReviewing into the development process.
Find out how to get started with #PullRequests in #AzureDevOps!
https://www.oliviervs.be/database-projects/database-projects-working-with-pull-requests/
-
The rise and fall of #peerreview - Why the greatest scientific experiment in history failed, and why that's a great thing
by Adam Mastroianni https://experimentalhistory.substack.com/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-peer-review#peerreviewing #science #research #publishing #journals
via @cpion
cc @Bernardpo -
"Peer Community In", un système alternatif de #publication scientifique
-
#IEEE Publisher retracts 400 papers at once for violations of ‘peer-review process policies’ – #Retraction Watch https://retractionwatch.com/2022/12/06/publisher-retracts-400-papers-at-once-for-violations-of-peer-review-process-policies/ #ethics #publishing #research #peerreviewing
-
Je me demande si HAL intègrera un jour un service de revue par les pairs #peerreviewing comme d'autres archives le font ? aRxiv, Peer Community In...
Quand les actes de colloque d'une sté FR sont diffusés directement sur HAL... https://cfa2022.sciencesconf.org/ -
Sur les plateformes @medrxiv et @medrxiv 7.3% des #preprints ont été commentés
Si le contenu de ce #peerreviewing est dans les standards des éditeurs, c'est encore peu
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.11.23.517621v1 -
New publication co-written with Thomas Guillemaud and Denis Bourguet in The Conversation-FR :
➡️ « Peer Community In », un système alternatif de publication scientifique
@TheConversationUS @PeerCommunityIn
#openscience #peerreviewing #pci #inrae #upvd -
« Pains and Gains of #PeerReviewing in #SoftwareEngineering: A Journal-Centric Perspective » by Nenad Medvidović https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3468744.3468748 — different journal than those I help editing, but I could've written basically the same note. Sustainability of peer review is a real issue.
