I am very disappointed with MIND. We don't need them spreading the "dangerous paranoid schizophrenic" trope as well.
The article quotes an "expert":
“People with schizophrenia do have an elevated risk of violence compared with the general population, even after accounting for socioeconomic factors, but the absolute risk is small. Only a minority will commit a serious violent act,” he said.
“That risk increases when other factors are present, particularly drug or alcohol problems, a history of violence, or having been a victim of violence themselves. The important point is that treatments we already have, and which are widely available, can bring that risk down.”
So basically, the risk of violence increases for the exact same reasons as for non schizophrenic people. What's the point of even mentioning the schizophrenia? Maybe we need more public awareness about how some people who catch the flu can go on to commit violence?
I accept of course that people with "schizophrenia" are often tired, confused, emotionally overwrought and desperate. If someone has a predisposition to violence, that pressure obviously won't help.
But linking an entire person's behavior to one diagnosis is the classic "trans broken arm" error. You have a broken arm, but you're trans, so let's refer you to a gender clinic.
Also no mention of the medical trauma that probably contributes to people's habituation to violence. Calocane had been sectioned multiple times and subjected to forced medication. That is traumatic even if it is "medical care".
Many studies have shown the "meds for life" model favored by western psychiatry does not lead to improved long term outcomes. The west has the worst outcomes for "schizophrenic" people, not the best. I am not anti medication, my own story is fighting (non violently) to get prescribed antipsychotics and I will never forget the relief they brought. But self-regulation, acceptance and evolving your relationship with your experiences are possible for many people, and this can help people reduce or end their antipsychotic medications.
I also note the treatment for Calocane's violence is presented in the article below as just schizophrenia meds. He's thought to be violent because of the schizophrenia, so treat the schizophrenia. But he should be treated for the violence and anger, separately from any medication regime.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/sep/05/mental-health-groups-have-failed-to-acknowledge-risk-of-violence-says-mind-chief
#mentalHealth #psychosis #mind #neurodivergent