home.social

#bigfive — Public Fediverse posts

Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #bigfive, aggregated by home.social.

  1. DATE: November 22, 2026 at 12:00PM
    SOURCE: PSYPOST.ORG

    ** Research quality varies widely from fantastic to small exploratory studies. Please check research methods when conclusions are very important to you. **
    -------------------------------------------------

    TITLE: Traits that make someone seem more intellectual can also make them seem less liberal, study suggests

    URL: psypost.org/traits-that-make-s

    People’s impressions of how politically liberal and how intellectual another person is do not behave like two expressions of a single broad personality trait, according to new experimental research published in Journal of Research in Personality. When participants evaluated fictional individuals from brief personality profiles, descriptions that boosted perceived intellect tended to lower perceived liberalism. The findings suggest that combining political attitudes and intellectual curiosity into one broad “openness to experience” score may obscure distinct underlying dimensions in how people judge others.

    In psychology, personality is commonly organized around the Big Five model, which groups traits into five broad domains: extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism, and openness to experience. Openness to experience refers to a person’s tendency to engage with new ideas, art, emotions, and unconventional values.

    Widely used personality questionnaires calculate a single overall openness score by adding together six narrower sub-traits, called facets. Two of those facets are intellect, which captures an interest in abstract or philosophical ideas, and liberalism, which reflects progressive political views and a willingness to question traditional rules or authority.

    Psychologists have debated whether these varied facets belong on a single psychological spectrum. In a 2007 study, researchers identified two distinct aspects within openness: an intellect aspect centered on reasoning and abstract thought, and an openness aspect centered on aesthetics, imagination, and sensory experience. Even though those two aspects were substantially correlated (with a correlation of .51), the authors argued they represent separate traits based on discriminant validity, meaning each aspect showed a different pattern of links with other Big Five domains.

    Later work pointed to similar splits in real-world behavior. For example, a 2016 study of more than 1,000 participants found that aesthetic openness tended to predict creative achievement in the arts, whereas intellect tended to predict creative achievement in the sciences. Still, as the authors of the new study note, showing that two traits correlate differently with outside outcomes does not by itself determine whether more than one underlying dimension is needed to explain them.

    Standard personality research usually evaluates trait structure with correlations and factor analysis, which examine how strongly questionnaire responses move together in a straight line rather than testing a stricter requirement for measuring a single trait, known as monotonicity. To test monotonicity directly, researchers can use state-trace analysis, a mathematical method developed in cognitive psychology that plots two measured outcomes against each other across groups or experimental conditions. If shifting from one condition to another moves one score upward while pulling the other downward, a single underlying dimension cannot account for the pattern.

    Using this approach, a 2025 analysis led by Johannes Titz, who also led the new study, examined self-report personality surveys from roughly 619,000 people and found that openness violated this single-dimension requirement far more widely than any other Big Five domain. Its departures were spread so broadly across facets that even dividing openness into two dimensions might not be enough, suggesting that as many dimensions as facets could be required.

    The sharpest departure appeared between liberalism and intellect, which formed a lopsided U-shaped curve: average intellect scores bottomed out among respondents in the middle-to-conservative range of the liberalism scale and rose in both directions from there, climbing far more steeply toward the liberal end.

    Because those earlier survey results were observational, the researchers set out to test whether controlled changes in information about a person would produce a similar split in personality perception, meaning how observers judge someone else’s traits. Earlier research on social impressions found that people readily infer another person’s political ideology from minimal behavioral descriptions, and those assumptions tend to stick even when alternative explanations for the behavior are offered. Building on this idea, Titz and Benedikt Gailer, whose master’s thesis formed the basis for the study, designed an experiment to see whether specific profile details would causally pull observers’ ratings of intellect and liberalism in opposite directions.

    “The Big Five are often presented as five basic dimensions of personality, but can personality really be reduced to those five dimensions?” lead author Johannes Titz, a postdoctoral researcher in Research Methods and Evaluation in Psychology at Chemnitz University of Technology in Germany, told PsyPost. “Earlier research suggested a problem with openness to experience: liberalism and intellect, usually grouped under openness, did not fit a single continuum. Across part of the political spectrum, greater conservatism was associated with higher—not lower—self-reported intellect, contradicting what a single openness continuum would predict. Benedikt Gailer and I wanted to investigate this experimentally by varying descriptions of fictitious people and examining how others judged them.”

    Before running the main experiment, the researchers conducted a pilot study with 42 participants using a simpler four-condition setup to estimate the needed sample size. The four-condition pilot test was not statistically significant, meaning it could not reject a single-dimension account, and simulations based on those data indicated that at least 105 participants would be needed for the main experiment.

    Separately, after inspecting the pilot results, the team decided to add a third level of artistic interest to map more of the relationship between the two traits and increase the study’s ability to detect a multi-dimensional pattern. The main study was not preregistered, though the authors made their data, study materials, and analysis code publicly available online.

    For the main experiment, the researchers recruited 116 German-speaking adults online through university mailing lists and social media. After excluding three respondents who missed multiple attention checks, the final sample included 113 participants with an average age of 28. Most participants were female, and about 70% were university students, the majority of whom were studying psychology.

    Participants read six brief written profiles describing a fictional woman named Ms. N., showing how she supposedly rated herself on six statements from a standard 120-item public-domain Big Five questionnaire. Participants were told to assume her self-ratings were completely accurate. Three statements measured self-efficacy, a facet of conscientiousness reflecting confidence and competence in completing tasks, such as “I excel in what I do” and “I know how to get things done.”

    Across the profiles, Ms. N. rated those self-efficacy statements as either inaccurate or accurate. The authors chose self-efficacy to challenge a single-dimension account because prior self-report data showed it correlates positively with intellect but slightly negatively with liberalism, while belonging to conscientiousness avoided overlapping wording with openness.

    To avoid simply engineering a split without giving a one-dimensional explanation a fair test, the researchers also varied a second trait, artistic interest, which tends to rise alongside both intellect and liberalism. Acting as a “trace factor” meant to shift overall perceived openness up and down, artistic interest was presented at three levels (inaccurate, neutral, or accurate) using statements about valuing art, liking poetry, and seeing beauty in things others might miss. Combining two levels of self-efficacy with three levels of artistic interest created six distinct profiles.

    Participants read all six profiles in a randomized order and rated Ms. N.’s perceived intellect and liberalism after each one, using four questions per trait on a five-point scale for total scores ranging from 4 to 20. Intellect items asked whether she enjoyed reading challenging material or avoided philosophical discussions, while liberalism items asked whether she tended to vote for liberal or conservative candidates, believed there is no absolute right or wrong, or favored being tough on crime. Two additional questions about completing tasks successfully and enjoying art museums served as checks to verify that participants read the profiles as intended.

    The researchers analyzed the responses in two ways. First, they conducted a between-subjects analysis using only the first profile each participant saw, providing ratings unaffected by carry-over from earlier profiles. Because profile order was randomized for each person, the six first-profile conditions were uneven, ranging from 14 to 25 participants each, though state-trace analysis does not require equal group sizes. Second, they ran a within-subjects analysis across all six profiles rated by 112 participants, excluding one person who reported mistaking multiple profiles for the same individual.

    The manipulation checks worked as expected, with ratings of task completion closely tracking the self-efficacy descriptions and ratings of museum enjoyment closely tracking the artistic interest descriptions. In both the first-profile analysis and the full six-profile analysis, state-trace testing indicated that a single underlying dimension could not adequately explain participants’ judgments of liberalism and intellect.

    At every level of artistic interest, whether low, medium, or high, changing the fictional target from low self-efficacy to high self-efficacy pushed perceived intellect upward while pulling perceived liberalism downward. Participants consistently judged a highly capable, task-oriented person to be more intellectual, yet less politically liberal, than a less capable person who shared the exact same interest in art. Because a single openness dimension would require both ratings to move in the same direction rather than diverging, at least two dimensions were required to accommodate the results.

    “Our findings challenge the idea that the Big Five represent five coherent underlying dimensions,” Titz explained. “In our experiment, judgments of liberalism and intellect required at least two dimensions, although both are commonly assigned to openness. Together with earlier self-report findings, this suggests that grouping characteristics under one label does not necessarily make them one measurable trait. Put simply, being less liberal does not invariably go together with being less intellectual.”

    Although both analyses pointed to the same divergence, the statistical evidence was stronger in the within-subjects data, which drew on all six ratings per person rather than the smaller first-profile groups, and intellect ratings spanned a wider range. On the 4-to-20 scale, a target low in both self-efficacy and artistic interest received an average intellect score of 7.62 across all six profiles, compared with 9.84 when viewed first. At the upper end, a target high in both traits averaged 16.79 across all profiles, compared with 15.06 when viewed first.

    “The important result is that the judgments followed a pattern that one underlying dimension could not explain,” Titz said. “The statistical evidence was clear, particularly when we analyzed all six judgments from each participant. In practical terms, combining liberalism and intellect into one openness score can obscure meaningful differences between them.”

    The authors suggest two possible explanations for this wider spread in ratings. One possibility is a contrast effect, where evaluating a low-scoring profile right before a high-scoring one makes the second target seem more extreme by comparison. Another possibility is that participants viewing only one profile mentally compare that target against different everyday baselines, such as judging a high-achieving profile against unusually talented people rather than an average person, whereas rating multiple profiles creates a shared reference point.

    In the authors’ reading, participants’ impressions may reflect a mixture of genuine real-world patterns and stereotype-based exaggeration rather than an arbitrary misconception. Research on moral stereotypes suggests that assumptions about liberals and conservatives often reproduce the direction of real group differences while magnifying their size. Prior survey studies indicate that political conservatism tends to align with higher conscientiousness, which in turn tends to link with higher intellect, even though higher intellect is also generally associated with liberalism. The researchers propose that these competing pathways may help explain why higher self-efficacy pulled perceived intellect and liberalism in opposite directions.

    At the same time, the authors note that summed openness scores can still serve as useful predictive composites. However, when contributing facets fail to follow a common order, that combined score cannot be interpreted straightforwardly as locating someone on a single continuous trait.

    The findings also speak to a broader debate over whether dividing personality domains into sub-traits already resolves the issue. In Titz’s earlier analysis of large self-report datasets, both neuroticism (a tendency toward negative emotions like anxiety and stress) and conscientiousness (being organized, disciplined, and goal-oriented) were nearly compatible with a single dimension across all six of their facets, with violations traceable to just one item in each domain.

    “A common response is that the Big Five already contain narrower facets, so additional complexity is expected,” Titz noted. “But having several named facets does not automatically mean that several underlying dimensions are needed. In my earlier research, neuroticism was compatible with a single dimension after setting aside one problematic item, despite including six facets. Openness showed much more widespread problems, suggesting that some Big Five domains form more coherent dimensions than others.”

    There are a few things to keep in mind when interpreting these findings. First, the experiment measured how observers judge brief written descriptions of fictional people, not how traits are actually organized inside real individuals. Because the profiles contained sparse background information, participants likely leaned on culturally shared assumptions or stereotypes about how traits and political views go together.

    Those assumptions may also vary across cultures, since political labels such as liberal and conservative carry different meanings in Germany than in the United States or other societies. In addition, roughly half of the participants were psychology students who may have been familiar with Big Five personality models, and all descriptions and ratings were drawn from one specific personality questionnaire, part of the public-domain International Personality Item Pool (IPIP).

    “We did not test whether liberals or conservatives are more intelligent: participants judged fictitious people, and we did not measure IQ,” Titz cautioned. “The experiment directly concerns personality perception; its broader relevance comes from its agreement with earlier self-report findings. We also used a particular Big Five questionnaire framework (IPIP) and a predominantly young, female, highly educated German sample, so generalization requires further testing. The study shows that one dimension is insufficient here, but does not establish the total number of personality dimensions.”

    To test whether this pattern holds up in more realistic settings, the researchers suggest recruiting more diverse samples and moving beyond brief written profiles. Presenting targets through short audio or video clips of simulated conversations, for example, could capture more lifelike impressions while maintaining experimental control. The authors also note that state-trace experiments could be used to examine other Big Five domains where sub-traits may pull apart, such as modesty and trust within agreeableness.

    “My broader goal is to improve psychological measurement: before treating a score as ‘more’ or ‘less’ of one characteristic, we should test whether it supports that interpretation,” Titz added. “Next steps include studying other personality characteristics, recruiting more diverse samples, and using richer descriptions or videos of the people being judged. I hope personality researchers will incorporate the evidence that liberalism and intellect cannot be reduced to one dimension into better models of personality.”

    The study, “Perceived liberalism and intellect cannot be reduced to a single openness dimension: A state-trace experiment,” was authored by Johannes Titz and Benedikt Gailer.

    URL: psypost.org/traits-that-make-s

    -------------------------------------------------

    Private, vetted email list for mental health professionals: clinicians-exchange.org

    Unofficial Psychology Today Xitter to toot feed at Psych Today Unofficial Bot @PTUnofficialBot

    -------------------------------------------------

    #psychology #counseling #socialwork #psychotherapy @psychotherapist @psychotherapists @psychology @socialpsych @socialwork @psychiatry #mentalhealth #psychiatry #healthcare #depression #psychotherapist #PersonalityPsychology #PsychologyResearch #BigFive #OpennessToExperience #IntellectualCuriosity #PoliticalPsychology #PersonalityTraits #SocialPerception #PsychologyStudy #ResearchNews

Share on Mastodon

Enter the server where you have an account.