Look Apple, I don’t disagree that [the granting of kTCCServiceAccessibility service to an app] is a huge security/privacy risk, in principle—moreso b/c of “agentic” products ,
& I don’t even disagree persistent nagging could be appropriate way to force apps/users to do better … _iff_ there are appropriate finer capabilities/entitlements to be used!
⸻
(Realistically here is what I want is:
•OpenLogi - grant input interpretation for some of the buttons of the mouse (MX 3). DriverKit probs can do
• SideBar & Timing - see a list of running applications’ windows, their titles & maybe another exposure of open file/URL. Like … a ScreenTime data stream?
• Raycast, Supercharge, & Sidebar - ability to see / manipulate window _frames_ (but not really contents): display/space, size/position, minimized/hidden. WM stuff
• BTT & Raycast (as Paletro)- menu bar items and triggering on specific user input [could go through Spotlight? if it indexed right. or expand Intents, you can even UAC it (first of each) if it’ll make you happy]
• BTT (for BTT mobile): yeah, it kinda needs full keyboard/mouse control for my use, but like … there is kTCCServiceRemoteDesktop I guess?
Apple /could/ just ship (even sell) a 1st party Remote Desktop app for iOS/iPadOS, and I’d probably use that tho
or serve RDP rather than just VNC and I’ll use Microsoft’s
Honestly if they just exposed local video/audio playback as an Airplay source w/ scrubbing and media keys that would cover a lot of my use cases (interestingly setting mac audio output to HomePod mini stereo pair kinda does this already, but its uneven)
⸻
you know what none of this is, remotely, at all? Per _target_ app bucketing!
does` kTCCServiceAccessibilityPerTarget` accomplish anything (for me)? not apparently
I’m not looking for “agentic”, personally; I’m looking for smoothed UX workflow & self-management
If I knew details of what apps a priori I’d mise en place & skip
so, for now, its
```
sudo defaults write /Library/Preferences/FeatureFlags/Domain/TCC AX_TRANSPARENCY_INDICATOR -dict Enabled -bool false
```
(thanks @itspdfu via /r/MacOSBeta)
& later… idk, hopefully Apple & can be sane when this shit is GA, but seems half-baked #macOS27 #LiveActivities #TCC #capabilities #rant