#perfectionism — Public Fediverse posts
Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #perfectionism, aggregated by home.social.
-
Psychotherapist explains a possible childhood reason you always procrastinate, and how to fix it
-
Psychotherapist explains a possible childhood reason you always procrastinate, and how to fix it
-
to find the silver lining:
large slow movements take time to gather momentum
but when they do they steamroll everything
i'm watching #ElSayed and #Mamdani here in the #USA and i am delighted:
people are waking up from their #perfectionism and #cynicism and figuring out they have to fucking participate, and not just sit on the sidelines and judge
so yes the wait is excrutiating
but relief is coming, as you say, and i also believe
-
to find the silver lining:
large slow movements take time to gather momentum
but when they do they steamroll everything
i'm watching #ElSayed and #Mamdani here in the #USA and i am delighted:
people are waking up from their #perfectionism and #cynicism and figuring out they have to fucking participate, and not just sit on the sidelines and judge
so yes the wait is excrutiating
but relief is coming, as you say, and i also believe
-
@gooba42 @majorlinux @obscurestar @Robotistry @ariaflame @aaron
some of these fucking #revolution cosplayers have no fucking clue they'd be dead in the first fifteen minutes
they think revolution is some magical cleansing hand of god
no
it's the same fucking thing we have with the #vote:
imperfect, dirty, nasty factions that you have to get over your #perfectionism about and choose a side
just with a lot more fucking blood. and less ability to not participate
fucking idiots
-
@gooba42 @majorlinux @obscurestar @Robotistry @ariaflame @aaron
some of these fucking #revolution cosplayers have no fucking clue they'd be dead in the first fifteen minutes
they think revolution is some magical cleansing hand of god
no
it's the same fucking thing we have with the #vote:
imperfect, dirty, nasty factions that you have to get over your #perfectionism about and choose a side
just with a lot more fucking blood. and less ability to not participate
fucking idiots
-
thank you PeaceNick!
#ElSayed is a blaring radioactive red klaxon for the #Left:
we #vote, we win, we change the world
you don't vote, you stew in whiny #perfectionism and cringe #cynicism, you only aid #MAGA
after El Sayed, anyone still in pathetic psychological failure mode should be pilloried for their loser existence of helping #fascism in their inaction
people are getting it! 😃 they're voting! 😍
VOTE MOTHERFUCKERS
LET'S TAKE BACK THIS STUPID FUCKING COUNTRY
💪 😤 ✅
-
thank you PeaceNick!
#ElSayed is a blaring radioactive red klaxon for the #Left:
we #vote, we win, we change the world
you don't vote, you stew in whiny #perfectionism and cringe #cynicism, you only aid #MAGA
after El Sayed, anyone still in pathetic psychological failure mode should be pilloried for their loser existence of helping #fascism in their inaction
people are getting it! 😃 they're voting! 😍
VOTE MOTHERFUCKERS
LET'S TAKE BACK THIS STUPID FUCKING COUNTRY
💪 😤 ✅
-
I have also read "Let Them" by Mel Robbins but am not sure I can recommend. It spoke to me in some aspects, left me shrugging shoulders in others. Nothing revolutionary, but it might be a good book for emotionally tougher times in life. Offers clear guidelines on how to stop pestering others and just letting them be.
In other words: stoicism for perfectionist women, I'd say.
#Bookstodon #Book
#LetThem
#MelRobbins
#SelfHelpBooks
#Stoicism
#Perfectionism -
I have also read "Let Them" by Mel Robbins but am not sure I can recommend. It spoke to me in some aspects, left me shrugging shoulders in others. Nothing revolutionary, but it might be a good book for emotionally tougher times in life. Offers clear guidelines on how to stop pestering others and just letting them be.
In other words: stoicism for perfectionist women, I'd say.
#Bookstodon #Book
#LetThem
#MelRobbins
#SelfHelpBooks
#Stoicism
#Perfectionism -
RE: https://mastodon.social/@benroyce/117040275439060545
UPDATE
this is an important race folks
a lot of people are watching
can the left take over the #Democrats?
#ElSayed currently ahead 52% to 44%
EARLY RESULTS
HE CAN STILL LOSE
as long as we #vote, we assure we end the spineless centrists
You vote right? right?
You don't just fucking whine #cynicism and #perfectionism and #helplessness and #entitlement online, right? right?
Better live results link:
https://apnews.com/projects/elections-2026/michigan-primary-results-us-senate/#Dem
(ht: @juliehuz )
-
RE: https://mastodon.social/@benroyce/117040275439060545
UPDATE
this is an important race folks
a lot of people are watching
can the left take over the #Democrats?
#ElSayed currently ahead 52% to 44%
EARLY RESULTS
HE CAN STILL LOSE
as long as we #vote, we assure we end the spineless centrists
You vote right? right?
You don't just fucking whine #cynicism and #perfectionism and #helplessness and #entitlement online, right? right?
Better live results link:
https://apnews.com/projects/elections-2026/michigan-primary-results-us-senate/#Dem
(ht: @juliehuz )
-
He uses Mindset Mastery, his bespoke blend of hypnosis, NLP, and coaching, to create rapid, deep, and lasting change.
Read more 👉 https://lttr.ai/AttlJ
-
Follow up:
https://mastodon.social/@benroyce/116709382859132554
" #India’s #education minister resigns amid #Cockroach #youth movement #protests"
Something everyone of every country needs to learn (many know, many don't):
You fight for something, you win
You sit there, in inert whiny #cynicism and fragile impotent #perfectionism: you aid malice in your #learnedHelplessness. You've been psychologically conditioned
Especially you, lazy entitled Americans
-
Follow up:
https://mastodon.social/@benroyce/116709382859132554
" #India’s #education minister resigns amid #Cockroach #youth movement #protests"
Something everyone of every country needs to learn (many know, many don't):
You fight for something, you win
You sit there, in inert whiny #cynicism and fragile impotent #perfectionism: you aid malice in your #learnedHelplessness. You've been psychologically conditioned
Especially you, lazy entitled Americans
-
Ah yes, the classic Silicon Valley dilemma: aiming for perfection or drowning in "overengineering" 🤯. Apparently, striving for a flawless solution is a heresy akin to using Internet Explorer in 2023. 🙄 Let's just agree that "good enough" is the new "perfect" and call it a day. 🙌
https://var0.xyz/posts/perfection-is-not-over-engineering.html #SiliconValley #Dilemmas #Overengineering #GoodEnough #Perfectionism #TechTrends #HackerNews #ngated -
Ah yes, the classic Silicon Valley dilemma: aiming for perfection or drowning in "overengineering" 🤯. Apparently, striving for a flawless solution is a heresy akin to using Internet Explorer in 2023. 🙄 Let's just agree that "good enough" is the new "perfect" and call it a day. 🙌
https://var0.xyz/posts/perfection-is-not-over-engineering.html #SiliconValley #Dilemmas #Overengineering #GoodEnough #Perfectionism #TechTrends #HackerNews #ngated -
Here's the thing; this language tracks gaps, it rarely tracks progress.
Read the full article: The Language of Not Enough
▸ https://lttr.ai/AtMPm -
#ICE kills another person
This time in #Maine
😩😔
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/biddeford-maine-ice-investigation-fatal-shooting-rcna587279
#SusanCollin's office is swarmed with #protesters chanting "vote her out"
YES!
They get it!
This is how we fix it
This is why we're even in this predicament: people didn't vote
Fuck you and your fucking #perfectionism
Fuck you and your fucking #cynicism
You have blood on your hands. You are to blame for these deaths as much as #MAGA if you did not vote, do not vote
#VOTE you fucking whiny useless motherfuckers
-
#ICE kills another person
This time in #Maine
😩😔
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/biddeford-maine-ice-investigation-fatal-shooting-rcna587279
#SusanCollin's office is swarmed with #protesters chanting "vote her out"
YES!
They get it!
This is how we fix it
This is why we're even in this predicament: people didn't vote
Fuck you and your fucking #perfectionism
Fuck you and your fucking #cynicism
You have blood on your hands. You are to blame for these deaths as much as #MAGA if you did not vote, do not vote
#VOTE you fucking whiny useless motherfuckers
-
@hex
Thanks for your observations about AI.Love your last paragraph:
"The only good side effect is that I had a mental block in my own art forever – it had to be perfect.
Now, imperfect art feels like a telltale sign that something was made by hand.
I cherish the imperfections in my art now. I lean into them. Its made me grow as an artist."
-
@hex
Thanks for your observations about AI.Love your last paragraph:
"The only good side effect is that I had a mental block in my own art forever – it had to be perfect.
Now, imperfect art feels like a telltale sign that something was made by hand.
I cherish the imperfections in my art now. I lean into them. Its made me grow as an artist."
-
What's worth examining is whether you've been listening to a pattern as though it were a verdict, treating its permanent dissatisfaction as proof of your work's actual state rather than as one particular habit of mind, running on repeat.
Read the full article: The Voice That Sounds Like Standards
▸ https://lttr.ai/As6K3 -
“If you optimize everything, you will always be unhappy.”*…
Phil Tinline on the history and consequences of the impulse to optimize businesses, markets, and governments…
Optimization means achieving a measurable objective—that is, maximizing or minimizing a given number. It requires controlling the inputs and processes that affect the objective, in order to find the most efficient way to achieve it. It draws on centuries of mathematical discovery, but it emerged in its modern form under the pressure of World War II and the need to manage the byzantine complexity of US military logistics.
In the summer of 1947, a Stanford-trained mathematical scientist named George Dantzig sat in his office at the Pentagon, laboring over US Air Force planning issues with a desk calculator. The problems he had dealt with during the war and since involved “an astronomical number of feasible solutions to choose from,” making it impossible to calculate which was the best. As he recalled, “Those in charge often do a hand-wave and say, ‘I’ve considered all the alternatives,’ but this is so much garbage.” All those leaders had to offer was that their “‘experience’ and ‘mature judgment’ would guide the way” by laying down rules that would limit the options.
The problem, Dantzig realized, was that “you could never find any direct relationship between the stated goal and the actions to achieve the goal.” The solution, he believed, was to formulate a complex real-world problem as a mathematical model. This could then be solved by what became Dantzig’s “simplex algorithm” (or “simplex method”), provided a precise goal was set as its “objective function.”
The simplex algorithm radically reduced the number of feasible solutions. It soon became clear that it could be brought to bear far beyond the military: “All one had to do,” Dantzig remembered, “was change the names of the columns and the rows, and it was applicable to an economic planning problem or to an industrial planning problem.”
In engineering, optimization was put to use in designing rockets and aircraft, and the shape of cars, wind turbines, and hydrofoils. It redefined manufacturing, circuit design, and the management of supply chains. Its impact is still visible in measures of the occurrence of the word “optimization” itself. Before 1950, the term was barely in use at all; thereafter, its frequency soared.
Economists embraced optimization too. An early application was in the development of “portfolio theory,” which, as the aerospace engineer Joaquim R. R. A. Martins and the computer scientist Andrew Ning put it, “formalized the idea of investment diversification, marking the birth of modern financial economics.”7 One important element of optimization in economics is the inclusion of constraining factors: Given a set level of income or cost, how can we maximize utility? But economics is not quite as scientifically determinable as engineering—it’s more exposed to messy, contradictory fellow humans. Here, optimization starts to look rather suboptimal…
… As computers have become ubiquitous, optimization has spread ever deeper into human life. In 2021, a trio of Stanford academics published a book titled System Error: Where Big Tech Went Wrong and How We Can Reboot. They observed: “What begins as a professional mind-set for the technologist easily becomes a more general orientation to life. … The paramount goal becomes removing friction from everyday activities, automating repetitive tasks, and finding ways to save time while improving outcomes.” US tech companies, for instance, are often led by software engineers, who manage their staff accordingly, measuring results against precisely set objectives. An over-dominant engineering mindset, System Error argued, is extending optimization beyond the areas where it can be effective.
This might surprise the tech analyst Dan Wang, whose 2025 bestseller Breakneck: China’s Quest to Engineer the Future argued that “an American elite, made up mostly of lawyers, excelling at obstruction” had much to learn from China’s “technocratic class, made up of mostly engineers, that excels at construction.” But even Wang admitted that engineering logic can be taken too far. “Sometimes, it feels like China’s leadership is made up entirely of hydraulic engineers,” he wrote, “who view the economy and society as liquid flows, as if all human activity—from mass production to reproduction—can be directed, restricted, increased, or blocked with the same ease as turning a series of valves.”
Given its mathematical foundations, optimization depends on having numerical data that can be adjusted to achieve the numerically expressed objective. As the American historian of science Theodore Porter showed in his 1995 study Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life, governments began to gather data at scale and to rely on it for decision-making for reasons similar to those set out by Dantzig—to get away from the subjective judgment of leaders.
However, Porter warned that while using numbers to exercise power objectively might be an attractive idea, it is also impossible to do. Even governments can’t count everything, and choosing what to leave out is an intensely political decision. Worse, Porter wrote, “numbers have often been an agency for acting on people, exercising power over them,” even turning people “into objects to be manipulated.” As Wang noted, in China the drive to meet numerical targets has sometimes taken a crushingly simple form, as with the government’s “one child” or “zero Covid” policies.
Even when optimizers aren’t sealing sick people in their homes, as the Chinese state did during the pandemic, they are often so focused on their objective that they don’t notice the damage they’re doing. Whatever is not relevant to the objective can be shrugged off as a so-called externality. Witness corporations optimizing their operations to maximize profits or the price of their shares. Some squeeze pay or working conditions; others pollute with abandon, or exploit their dominant market position to force down their suppliers’ prices, regardless of the impact.
And the problem with optimization is not just a matter of unfortunate side-effects. We are seeing the emergence of what we might call “social optimization”—the belief that this idea offers a way to transform society as a whole. But as Porter’s work suggests, this is not a matter of neutrally making things better. Optimization privileges the measurable over the unmeasurable. And it places the onus for improving society on the ever-striving individual rather than asking more fundamental, structural questions about why systems work as they do and whom they empower and disempower.
This is not an explicit ideology. No doubt, businesses and governments often are simply following the logic and opportunities implicit in new digital technology, from smartphones to the cameras and sensors that can now cheaply and efficiently monitor a wide range of activities. Nonetheless, as new technology has made it possible to gather ever more numerical data, optimization has begun to embed its implicit values into our lives.
In the workplace, this can swiftly make people’s lives worse. Particularly in sectors such as logistics, new technology allows employers to optimize more and more rigorously for maximum productivity and minimum cost. It has become commonplace to give employees an ongoing score, with the aim of incentivizing them to compete continually. This goes beyond even the monitoring of worker efficiency that the management consultant Frederick Taylor pioneered in the early twentieth century and the numerical key performance indicators that his successors promoted. The intensive quantification of employees’ performance has come to be known as “digital Taylorism.”
Optimization has refocused the media around the measurable preferences of the individual, as tallied in clicks, page views, unique browses, and similar metrics. This erodes the shared moments that build a culture and the shared truths that underpin democracy. Social media takes this even further: Algorithms are optimized to maximize attention, incentivizing people to respond to political issues not with thought but vivid expressions of feeling, rewarding users numerically in follows, likes, and shares. Meanwhile, tracking apps increasingly normalize the optimization of health metrics.
Yet technologists are keen to go much further. Off the back of their successes producing software, they are raising their sights to the horizon, optimizing for a few grand objectives at all costs, in pursuit of an ever more perfect world. They have formed an alliance with philosophers and philanthropists in the Effective Altruism movement, which aims to purge generosity of the influence of feeling in favor of calculable reason—even as it confidently prophesies the far future. Other tech leaders support the principles of the “network state.” According to the journalist Gil Duran, this concept proposes to create “private, corporate-controlled cities” that will liberate innovators from the constraints of the democratic state and its messy, unmeasurable trade-offs.13
And most of all, the dream of social optimization reverberates through promises of an AI-transformed future, in which once unthinkably efficient tech will supposedly liberate individual human potential. In “The Techno-Optimist Manifesto” (2023), the venture capitalist Marc Andreessen proposed using technology and the free market to maximize abundance to the point of infinity. Though Andreessen insists he does not believe in “the Unconstrained Vision of Utopia,” he dismisses the “Precautionary Principle” as an “enemy.”
The problem here is obvious to anyone not immersed in the culture of Silicon Valley. Not every worthwhile objective can be measured. How do we quantify social peace, for instance, or the health of our arts and culture, or the concentration of power? Or the worth of work itself, or a truly enriching education, or kindness? We might hope the realization that not everything can be measured would prompt the promoters of social optimization to accept its limitations and appreciate the qualities of more deeply rooted systems, such as democracy. Alas, they tend to conclude that if a goal or a problem has no measure, it is not worth bothering with. Kevin Kelly, a technology journalist and an apostle of the Quantified Self movement, has faced criticism, as he puts it, that “only intangibles like meaningful happiness count.” His response: “Meaningfulness is very hard to measure, which makes it very hard to optimize.” Similarly, in a critique of the US anti-monopoly movement, the journalist Matthew Yglesias has protested that “‘corporate power’ doesn’t mean anything” on the grounds that it “doesn’t add up to anything measurable or actionable.”
But this is not the first time similar-sounding criticisms have been raised against attempts to perfect society. Where they chose to focus their fire, and where they didn’t, reveals what’s distinctive about the phenomenon of social optimization…
[Tinline reaches back to the early 19th century (and the earliest known use of the word “optimize”) then follows the development of what has become a powerful mindset– in effect, a movement. He concludes…]
Governments today do have something to learn from Dantzig’s insistence on the importance of having a clear objective. But his overly dim view of leadership needs to be constrained. It is increasingly clear that, in the less calculable areas of life, a leader exercising human judgment is preferable to an implacable optimization algorithm. Without such human-centered constraints in place, social optimization won’t make things better—only more extreme.
On not letting the perfect be the enemy of the possible– and often the preferable: “The Cult of Optimization,” from @philtinline.bsky.social in The Ideas Letter.
We should note that the optimization craze has taken hold at the personal level as well, with similar results. See. e.g., “Optimising is just perfectionism in disguise. Here’s why that’s a problem” and “Optimization Culture Is Making Us Miserable.”
* Donald Knuth (the godfather of computer programming)
###
As we celebrate slack and internalize externalities, we might spare a thought for a man who looked beyond the metrics od his day, Clifford W. Beers; he died on this date in 1943. An author and psychiatric patient, he is best known as the founder of the American mental hygiene movement.
#business #CliffordBeers #CliffordWBeers #culture #history #mentalHealth #mentalHygiene #optimization #perfectionism #politics #Science #TechnologyClifford Whittingham Beers was an American author and social reformer who wrote an autobiography documenting appalling conditions and maltreatment by staff of mental patients. His classic book, A Mind That Found Itself (1908) raised public consciousness of the need for reform. He had already himself experienced treatment as a mental patient, first in 1900, diagnosed with depression and paranoia. His four siblings also suffered mental health problems and died in mental hospitals, as he also did. In 1909, Beers founded the National Committee for Mental Hygiene (since renamed as Mental Health America) with the mission to improve the treatment in mental health institutions. By 1913, he was able to establish the Clifford Beers Clinic in New Haven, an outpatient mental health clinic, the first of its kind in the U.S., which continues his legacy to the present. – source
-
“If you optimize everything, you will always be unhappy.”*…
Phil Tinline on the history and consequences of the impulse to optimize businesses, markets, and governments…
Optimization means achieving a measurable objective—that is, maximizing or minimizing a given number. It requires controlling the inputs and processes that affect the objective, in order to find the most efficient way to achieve it. It draws on centuries of mathematical discovery, but it emerged in its modern form under the pressure of World War II and the need to manage the byzantine complexity of US military logistics.
In the summer of 1947, a Stanford-trained mathematical scientist named George Dantzig sat in his office at the Pentagon, laboring over US Air Force planning issues with a desk calculator. The problems he had dealt with during the war and since involved “an astronomical number of feasible solutions to choose from,” making it impossible to calculate which was the best. As he recalled, “Those in charge often do a hand-wave and say, ‘I’ve considered all the alternatives,’ but this is so much garbage.” All those leaders had to offer was that their “‘experience’ and ‘mature judgment’ would guide the way” by laying down rules that would limit the options.
The problem, Dantzig realized, was that “you could never find any direct relationship between the stated goal and the actions to achieve the goal.” The solution, he believed, was to formulate a complex real-world problem as a mathematical model. This could then be solved by what became Dantzig’s “simplex algorithm” (or “simplex method”), provided a precise goal was set as its “objective function.”
The simplex algorithm radically reduced the number of feasible solutions. It soon became clear that it could be brought to bear far beyond the military: “All one had to do,” Dantzig remembered, “was change the names of the columns and the rows, and it was applicable to an economic planning problem or to an industrial planning problem.”
In engineering, optimization was put to use in designing rockets and aircraft, and the shape of cars, wind turbines, and hydrofoils. It redefined manufacturing, circuit design, and the management of supply chains. Its impact is still visible in measures of the occurrence of the word “optimization” itself. Before 1950, the term was barely in use at all; thereafter, its frequency soared.
Economists embraced optimization too. An early application was in the development of “portfolio theory,” which, as the aerospace engineer Joaquim R. R. A. Martins and the computer scientist Andrew Ning put it, “formalized the idea of investment diversification, marking the birth of modern financial economics.”7 One important element of optimization in economics is the inclusion of constraining factors: Given a set level of income or cost, how can we maximize utility? But economics is not quite as scientifically determinable as engineering—it’s more exposed to messy, contradictory fellow humans. Here, optimization starts to look rather suboptimal…
… As computers have become ubiquitous, optimization has spread ever deeper into human life. In 2021, a trio of Stanford academics published a book titled System Error: Where Big Tech Went Wrong and How We Can Reboot. They observed: “What begins as a professional mind-set for the technologist easily becomes a more general orientation to life. … The paramount goal becomes removing friction from everyday activities, automating repetitive tasks, and finding ways to save time while improving outcomes.” US tech companies, for instance, are often led by software engineers, who manage their staff accordingly, measuring results against precisely set objectives. An over-dominant engineering mindset, System Error argued, is extending optimization beyond the areas where it can be effective.
This might surprise the tech analyst Dan Wang, whose 2025 bestseller Breakneck: China’s Quest to Engineer the Future argued that “an American elite, made up mostly of lawyers, excelling at obstruction” had much to learn from China’s “technocratic class, made up of mostly engineers, that excels at construction.” But even Wang admitted that engineering logic can be taken too far. “Sometimes, it feels like China’s leadership is made up entirely of hydraulic engineers,” he wrote, “who view the economy and society as liquid flows, as if all human activity—from mass production to reproduction—can be directed, restricted, increased, or blocked with the same ease as turning a series of valves.”
Given its mathematical foundations, optimization depends on having numerical data that can be adjusted to achieve the numerically expressed objective. As the American historian of science Theodore Porter showed in his 1995 study Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life, governments began to gather data at scale and to rely on it for decision-making for reasons similar to those set out by Dantzig—to get away from the subjective judgment of leaders.
However, Porter warned that while using numbers to exercise power objectively might be an attractive idea, it is also impossible to do. Even governments can’t count everything, and choosing what to leave out is an intensely political decision. Worse, Porter wrote, “numbers have often been an agency for acting on people, exercising power over them,” even turning people “into objects to be manipulated.” As Wang noted, in China the drive to meet numerical targets has sometimes taken a crushingly simple form, as with the government’s “one child” or “zero Covid” policies.
Even when optimizers aren’t sealing sick people in their homes, as the Chinese state did during the pandemic, they are often so focused on their objective that they don’t notice the damage they’re doing. Whatever is not relevant to the objective can be shrugged off as a so-called externality. Witness corporations optimizing their operations to maximize profits or the price of their shares. Some squeeze pay or working conditions; others pollute with abandon, or exploit their dominant market position to force down their suppliers’ prices, regardless of the impact.
And the problem with optimization is not just a matter of unfortunate side-effects. We are seeing the emergence of what we might call “social optimization”—the belief that this idea offers a way to transform society as a whole. But as Porter’s work suggests, this is not a matter of neutrally making things better. Optimization privileges the measurable over the unmeasurable. And it places the onus for improving society on the ever-striving individual rather than asking more fundamental, structural questions about why systems work as they do and whom they empower and disempower.
This is not an explicit ideology. No doubt, businesses and governments often are simply following the logic and opportunities implicit in new digital technology, from smartphones to the cameras and sensors that can now cheaply and efficiently monitor a wide range of activities. Nonetheless, as new technology has made it possible to gather ever more numerical data, optimization has begun to embed its implicit values into our lives.
In the workplace, this can swiftly make people’s lives worse. Particularly in sectors such as logistics, new technology allows employers to optimize more and more rigorously for maximum productivity and minimum cost. It has become commonplace to give employees an ongoing score, with the aim of incentivizing them to compete continually. This goes beyond even the monitoring of worker efficiency that the management consultant Frederick Taylor pioneered in the early twentieth century and the numerical key performance indicators that his successors promoted. The intensive quantification of employees’ performance has come to be known as “digital Taylorism.”
Optimization has refocused the media around the measurable preferences of the individual, as tallied in clicks, page views, unique browses, and similar metrics. This erodes the shared moments that build a culture and the shared truths that underpin democracy. Social media takes this even further: Algorithms are optimized to maximize attention, incentivizing people to respond to political issues not with thought but vivid expressions of feeling, rewarding users numerically in follows, likes, and shares. Meanwhile, tracking apps increasingly normalize the optimization of health metrics.
Yet technologists are keen to go much further. Off the back of their successes producing software, they are raising their sights to the horizon, optimizing for a few grand objectives at all costs, in pursuit of an ever more perfect world. They have formed an alliance with philosophers and philanthropists in the Effective Altruism movement, which aims to purge generosity of the influence of feeling in favor of calculable reason—even as it confidently prophesies the far future. Other tech leaders support the principles of the “network state.” According to the journalist Gil Duran, this concept proposes to create “private, corporate-controlled cities” that will liberate innovators from the constraints of the democratic state and its messy, unmeasurable trade-offs.13
And most of all, the dream of social optimization reverberates through promises of an AI-transformed future, in which once unthinkably efficient tech will supposedly liberate individual human potential. In “The Techno-Optimist Manifesto” (2023), the venture capitalist Marc Andreessen proposed using technology and the free market to maximize abundance to the point of infinity. Though Andreessen insists he does not believe in “the Unconstrained Vision of Utopia,” he dismisses the “Precautionary Principle” as an “enemy.”
The problem here is obvious to anyone not immersed in the culture of Silicon Valley. Not every worthwhile objective can be measured. How do we quantify social peace, for instance, or the health of our arts and culture, or the concentration of power? Or the worth of work itself, or a truly enriching education, or kindness? We might hope the realization that not everything can be measured would prompt the promoters of social optimization to accept its limitations and appreciate the qualities of more deeply rooted systems, such as democracy. Alas, they tend to conclude that if a goal or a problem has no measure, it is not worth bothering with. Kevin Kelly, a technology journalist and an apostle of the Quantified Self movement, has faced criticism, as he puts it, that “only intangibles like meaningful happiness count.” His response: “Meaningfulness is very hard to measure, which makes it very hard to optimize.” Similarly, in a critique of the US anti-monopoly movement, the journalist Matthew Yglesias has protested that “‘corporate power’ doesn’t mean anything” on the grounds that it “doesn’t add up to anything measurable or actionable.”
But this is not the first time similar-sounding criticisms have been raised against attempts to perfect society. Where they chose to focus their fire, and where they didn’t, reveals what’s distinctive about the phenomenon of social optimization…
[Tinline reaches back to the early 19th century (and the earliest known use of the word “optimize”) then follows the development of what has become a powerful mindset– in effect, a movement. He concludes…]
Governments today do have something to learn from Dantzig’s insistence on the importance of having a clear objective. But his overly dim view of leadership needs to be constrained. It is increasingly clear that, in the less calculable areas of life, a leader exercising human judgment is preferable to an implacable optimization algorithm. Without such human-centered constraints in place, social optimization won’t make things better—only more extreme.
On not letting the perfect be the enemy of the possible– and often the preferable: “The Cult of Optimization,” from @philtinline.bsky.social in The Ideas Letter.
We should note that the optimization craze has taken hold at the personal level as well, with similar results. See. e.g., “Optimising is just perfectionism in disguise. Here’s why that’s a problem” and “Optimization Culture Is Making Us Miserable.”
* Donald Knuth (the godfather of computer programming)
###
As we celebrate slack and internalize externalities, we might spare a thought for a man who looked beyond the metrics od his day, Clifford W. Beers; he died on this date in 1943. An author and psychiatric patient, he is best known as the founder of the American mental hygiene movement.
#business #CliffordBeers #CliffordWBeers #culture #history #mentalHealth #mentalHygiene #optimization #perfectionism #politics #Science #TechnologyClifford Whittingham Beers was an American author and social reformer who wrote an autobiography documenting appalling conditions and maltreatment by staff of mental patients. His classic book, A Mind That Found Itself (1908) raised public consciousness of the need for reform. He had already himself experienced treatment as a mental patient, first in 1900, diagnosed with depression and paranoia. His four siblings also suffered mental health problems and died in mental hospitals, as he also did. In 1909, Beers founded the National Committee for Mental Hygiene (since renamed as Mental Health America) with the mission to improve the treatment in mental health institutions. By 1913, he was able to establish the Clifford Beers Clinic in New Haven, an outpatient mental health clinic, the first of its kind in the U.S., which continues his legacy to the present. – source
-
✮ Get It Started ✮
Subscribe to keep reading
Become a paid subscriber to get access to the rest of this post and other exclusive content.
Subscribe #Accountability #Achievement #AchievingGoals #ActionOverPerfection #Anxiety #BeatProcrastination #Bones #BuildMomentum #BuildingBetterHabits #Consistency #ConsistentProgress #CreativeNonfiction #creativeWriting #Deadlines #DeepWork #DelayedGratification #digitalDistractions #Discipline #Distractions #DoItNow #EffectivePlanning #EmotionalGrowth #Erwinism #EverydayPhilosophy #FearOfFailure #FinishWhatYouStart #Flesh #Focus #FYP #Garden #GoalAchievement #GoalSetting #Goals #HabitFormation #HumanBehavior #Inferno #Inspiration #InspirationalWriting #IntentionalLiving #Leader #Learning #Life #LifeLessons #LiteraryEssay #LiteraryProse #LivingWithPurpose #Love #MakeTodayCount #ManagingDistractions #MindfulLiving #Motivation #MotivationToStart #MotivationalEssay #NeverTooLate #NoPerfectTime #OvercomingFear #OvercomingProcrastination #Perfectionism #PersonalDevelopment #PersonalGrowth #personalResponsibility #PetPeeve #PhilosophicalWriting #PlanningAhead #PoeticProse #PomodoroTechnique #Prioritization #Prioritizing #Procrastination #Productivity #ProductivityMindset #ProductivityTips #ProfessionalGrowth #Progress #PsychologyOfProcrastination #ReflectiveWriting #Resilience #Retrospective #SeizeTheDay #SelfConfidence #SelfDiscipline #selfImprovement #SelfReflection #SocialMediaAddiction #StopProcrastinating #StopWaiting #Stress #SuccessHabits #SuccessMindset #TakingAction #TimeIsPrecious #TimeManagement #TomorrowS #Tsunamis #Urgency #WisdomForLife #WorkEthic -
🚀 Behold the "Best Simple System for Now," where complex buzzwords go to die! Dan North graces us with the revelation that #perfectionism and #pragmatism are not mutually exclusive—who knew? 🙄 In just 26 minutes, this masterpiece of redundancy assures us that we can have our cake and eat it too, if only we follow the sacred tenets of #XML streaming and #JSON library worship. 🍰💻
https://dannorth.net/blog/best-simple-system-for-now/ #BestSimpleSystem #HackerNews #ngated -
🚀 Behold the "Best Simple System for Now," where complex buzzwords go to die! Dan North graces us with the revelation that #perfectionism and #pragmatism are not mutually exclusive—who knew? 🙄 In just 26 minutes, this masterpiece of redundancy assures us that we can have our cake and eat it too, if only we follow the sacred tenets of #XML streaming and #JSON library worship. 🍰💻
https://dannorth.net/blog/best-simple-system-for-now/ #BestSimpleSystem #HackerNews #ngated -
Never too late: I have had a Wikipedia account for 16 years and only made my first edit yesterday.
-
an important caveat:
you can't build #community with people animated by anti-community instincts
that means #cynicism and #perfectionism
people identify these weaknesses unfortunately with #leftism
but real leftism is effective action for a cause. leftism is not a psychological problem that immobilizes you
the same way we say we can't advance #society by including #bigotry or lies. we need to exclude such voices or nothing gets done
they can come around on their own
-
an important caveat:
you can't build #community with people animated by anti-community instincts
that means #cynicism and #perfectionism
people identify these weaknesses unfortunately with #leftism
but real leftism is effective action for a cause. leftism is not a psychological problem that immobilizes you
the same way we say we can't advance #society by including #bigotry or lies. we need to exclude such voices or nothing gets done
they can come around on their own
-
Notice the hobbyist #crank #edgelords who harp on #perfectionism on #socialMedia including #Fediverse/ #Mastodon
Such accounts work hard for #MAGA to win. Purposefully or cluelessly
It's #voterSuppression
High holy fire and brimstone #purityPolitics #drama is easy. Anyone can manufacture it. It's not #morality it's cheap #dopamine hits
How to spot #fake #leftist accounts:
Is their message
an appeal of #psychology?
Amping #cynicism and #toxicIdealism is a #scam
-
Notice the hobbyist #crank #edgelords who harp on #perfectionism on #socialMedia including #Fediverse/ #Mastodon
Such accounts work hard for #MAGA to win. Purposefully or cluelessly
It's #voterSuppression
High holy fire and brimstone #purityPolitics #drama is easy. Anyone can manufacture it. It's not #morality it's cheap #dopamine hits
How to spot #fake #leftist accounts:
Is their message
an appeal of #psychology?
Amping #cynicism and #toxicIdealism is a #scam
-
@n1xnx @Scrimshaw9 @eschaton @mastodonmigration @katrinakatrinka
all those not voting and whining it's the right choice are victims or mongers of a #perfectionism and #cynicism #psyop
expressing no real #leftist ideological position, merely manifesting psychological issues
as an aspect of their genuine sad existence
or as an aspect of being a #rightWing #troll cosplaying #left to suppress the left #vote
what matters is effective #harmReduction
perfection is for losers
literally
-
@n1xnx @Scrimshaw9 @eschaton @mastodonmigration @katrinakatrinka
all those not voting and whining it's the right choice are victims or mongers of a #perfectionism and #cynicism #psyop
expressing no real #leftist ideological position, merely manifesting psychological issues
as an aspect of their genuine sad existence
or as an aspect of being a #rightWing #troll cosplaying #left to suppress the left #vote
what matters is effective #harmReduction
perfection is for losers
literally
-
@Scrimshaw9 @katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #USA military funding to #Israel
So with #Harris we forget #transphobia and #womensRights
We focus on the #genocide in #Gaza
Now with Platner we forget about genocide in Gaza
we focus on transphobia and women's rights
so people don't #vote, #GOP wins…
the genocide in Gaza gets all the greenlights, transphobia advances, and women's rights get curtailed
the power of #perfectionism
-
@Scrimshaw9 @katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #USA military funding to #Israel
So with #Harris we forget #transphobia and #womensRights
We focus on the #genocide in #Gaza
Now with Platner we forget about genocide in Gaza
we focus on transphobia and women's rights
so people don't #vote, #GOP wins…
the genocide in Gaza gets all the greenlights, transphobia advances, and women's rights get curtailed
the power of #perfectionism
-
@Scrimshaw9 @katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
i would say that #Platner fucking sucks, but not voting and helping the #GOP win sucks much more
do you want Platner, with all of his sins in that seat?
or the GOP and their agenda, if you truly care about #womensRights and opposing Nazis, transphobes, homophobes, and racists
and what we are drowning in as a country is the inability to make that determination
because #perfectionism and #cynicism
-
@Scrimshaw9 @katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
i would say that #Platner fucking sucks, but not voting and helping the #GOP win sucks much more
do you want Platner, with all of his sins in that seat?
or the GOP and their agenda, if you truly care about #womensRights and opposing Nazis, transphobes, homophobes, and racists
and what we are drowning in as a country is the inability to make that determination
because #perfectionism and #cynicism
-
@katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
yes we are in quite a sad state
and why are we in this sad state?
#MAGA and nonvoters
the #socialMedia manipulation is to amplify the #bigotry vote on the right
and suppress the left vote
do you recognize or care that you are selling psychological manipulation, #cynicism and #perfectionism, as "leftist", no real ideological position in that, in such a way that you suppress the #left #vote and help MAGA and #Likud?
-
@katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
yes we are in quite a sad state
and why are we in this sad state?
#MAGA and nonvoters
the #socialMedia manipulation is to amplify the #bigotry vote on the right
and suppress the left vote
do you recognize or care that you are selling psychological manipulation, #cynicism and #perfectionism, as "leftist", no real ideological position in that, in such a way that you suppress the #left #vote and help MAGA and #Likud?
-
@katrinakatrinka @TagYourToe @mastodonmigration
but reality does change when we see and denounce the simple #psyop games to kill the #left
it's not "complexity" it's simple human weakness: #cynicism and #perfectionism
play psychological games on that, and you can change #elections, and reward #MAGA and #Likud
we see you
-
@katrinakatrinka @TagYourToe @mastodonmigration
but reality does change when we see and denounce the simple #psyop games to kill the #left
it's not "complexity" it's simple human weakness: #cynicism and #perfectionism
play psychological games on that, and you can change #elections, and reward #MAGA and #Likud
we see you
-
@katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #US military funding to #Israel
now you understand the real purpose behind goosing #perfectionism on the #left to suppress #leftist turnout in the #vote
it is artificially manufactured noise for a #psyop
show me someone upset at Platner's sins, moved to not vote, resulting in a GOP win and all the green lights for Israel to #genocide more, and i'll show you a patsy manipulated by #Likud #trolls
-
@katrinakatrinka @mastodonmigration
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #US military funding to #Israel
now you understand the real purpose behind goosing #perfectionism on the #left to suppress #leftist turnout in the #vote
it is artificially manufactured noise for a #psyop
show me someone upset at Platner's sins, moved to not vote, resulting in a GOP win and all the green lights for Israel to #genocide more, and i'll show you a patsy manipulated by #Likud #trolls
-
correct
then the point for us is to construct effective destruction of #usa complicity in #genocide
which we do not achieve with #perfectionism
i'm not accusing you of that, i'm pointing out the larger effort at work here to goose perfectionist instincts, and suppress #leftist turnout, and ensure a #GOP win
allowing the genocide to go full steam ahead
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #US military funding to #Israel
-
correct
then the point for us is to construct effective destruction of #usa complicity in #genocide
which we do not achieve with #perfectionism
i'm not accusing you of that, i'm pointing out the larger effort at work here to goose perfectionist instincts, and suppress #leftist turnout, and ensure a #GOP win
allowing the genocide to go full steam ahead
#Platner has consistently campaigned on a platform of halting #US military funding to #Israel
-
RE: https://mas.to/@skeletor/116642169373760797
I'm much more productive when I can internalize and remember this philosophy. I often either don't start or don't finish projects because I try to do everything perfectly, when "good enough" is what is called for.
-
RE: https://mas.to/@skeletor/116642169373760797
I'm much more productive when I can internalize and remember this philosophy. I often either don't start or don't finish projects because I try to do everything perfectly, when "good enough" is what is called for.
-
What makes you an artist? 🎨🎶
#artist #creative #creativity #art #music #musician #painter #poet #painting #songwriter #perfectionism #poetry #playmusic #independentmusician #musicians #songwriting #musicquotes #musiclovers #makeart
#expression #inspirationalquotes #quotes #artquotes #quote #motivation #inspiration #motivationalquotes #quoteoftheday #creativeart #mindset #artlovers #lifequotes #makearteveryday #creativeprocess #creativeexpression #work #vulnerability -
What makes you an artist? 🎨🎶
#artist #creative #creativity #art #music #musician #painter #poet #painting #songwriter #perfectionism #poetry #playmusic #independentmusician #musicians #songwriting #musicquotes #musiclovers #makeart
#expression #inspirationalquotes #quotes #artquotes #quote #motivation #inspiration #motivationalquotes #quoteoftheday #creativeart #mindset #artlovers #lifequotes #makearteveryday #creativeprocess #creativeexpression #work #vulnerability -
PAUL DROTOS’ GUIDE FOR YOUR IMPROV JOURNEY
Your Improv Journey is Paul Drotos’ treatise meant for beginners, veterans and randos. It is an easy read and is relevant even when considering teamwork, community and art in general.
Improv is an art form where actors create scenes on the spot. In a show, troupes will usually have games they play with varying levels of audience input.
When the scene ends, that is the end of […]
https://www.communityedition.ca/paul-drotos-guide-for-your-improv-journey/ -
I have always found it difficult to adopt a carefree attitude and just "go with the flow". When on holiday, it is more likely that I will create a detailed itinerary and obsess about visiting every possible attraction, regardless of whether this may be detrimental to my enjoyment. As ridiculous as it sounds, failure to do this can result in me feeling as if I have somehow failed to complete the task that I have assigned myself.
During this weekend's trip to Chester (which was a birthday present from my wonderful wife), however, the most enjoyable aspect was simply walking around without a plan or having to stick to times. There is an abundance of historical sites and impressive architecture in Chester, but I was happy to visit only what was convenient. Maybe there's hope for me yet 😃
#neurodivergent #adhd #obsession #AuDHD #ActuallyAutistic #neurospicy #perfectionism #perfectionist