home.social

#namecalling — Public Fediverse posts

Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #namecalling, aggregated by home.social.

  1. CW: how name-calling works, 2/n

    @roko_basilisk

    As in "Sticks and stones may break my.bones but words will never hurt me"?

    Maybe you've found that to be true for you on an individual level - or at least a useful affirmation - but in general it's not true. Words can hurt people both directly and indirectly.

    Name-calling hurts people directly.

    Stigma has other knock-on effects: for example, doctors hold prejudices about the implications of being fat, and that leads to fat people getting materially worse medical treatment on average.

    In this case, we're talking about the effects of prejudice about certain types of medication. Could include worse medical treatment, fewer job opportunities (where bosses are for some reason aware), or people self-selecting out of trying those drugs when they could have been helpful.

    "The habit, very prevalent to-day, of dismissing words as “just words” takes no account of their power. But once the Idea has entered into other minds, it will tend to reincarnate itself there... It may for some time only incarnate itself in more words, more books, more speeches; but the day comes when it incarnates itself in actions, and this is its day of judgment."
    - Dorothy L Sayers

    I think you're right that prejudices can be mitigated _to an extent_ by education. But stigma isn't necessarily rational in the first place, so it isn't necessarily going to go away through rational discussion. So, wouldn't part of that education be this very conversation about not invoking the drug names as put-downs?

    #namecalling #putdowns #stigma #language

  2. CW: how name-calling works

    @roko_basilisk

    I think the point is more like: by using a word as a name-calling word, you're validating and amplifying any culturally negative valence it already had.

    For example, if you call someone "fat" as a put-down, you're invoking existing stigma around being fat. Simultaneously you're also yourself perpetuating the stigma, because you've slotted the fatness variable into a context (put-downs, name-calling) which requires a stigmatised description. Choosing the word "fat" as your put-down-word implies "this description is a bad thing".

    (Most humans, most of the time, pick up the language context, and detect when a description is intended as a put-down. They can tell the difference from using the same word in a neutrally-descriptive or celebratory way. Sometimes there is a bit of ambiguity though, in either direction.)

    @thomasfuchs is asking people not to use drug names as elements in put-downs, because doing so validates and amplifies the negative associations that some drugs already have in present-day culture(s).

    #namecalling #putdowns #stigma #language

Share on Mastodon

Enter the server where you have an account.