home.social

#middleearth — Public Fediverse posts

Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #middleearth, aggregated by home.social.

  1. Q: Why Would The Valar Not Accept The One Ring If It Were Sent Over Sea?

    ANSWER: I received the following lengthy, thoughtful question in December 2025:

    In the Council of Elrond, when taking the Ring to Valinor for destruction/safekeeping/whatever is brought up, Elrond says the Valar wouldn’t take it and Gandalf says that it’s their (the peoples of M.E.) problem to solve for all time anyway. […]

    https://middle-earth.xenite.org/why-would-the-valar-not-accept-the-one-ring-if-it-were-sent-over-sea/
  2. Q: Why Would The Valar Not Accept The One Ring If It Were Sent Over Sea?

    ANSWER: I received the following lengthy, thoughtful question in December 2025:

    In the Council of Elrond, when taking the Ring to Valinor for destruction/safekeeping/whatever is brought up, Elrond says the Valar wouldn’t take it and Gandalf says that it’s their (the peoples of M.E.) problem to solve for all time anyway. […]

    https://middle-earth.xenite.org/why-would-the-valar-not-accept-the-one-ring-if-it-were-sent-over-sea/
  3. Q: Why Would The Valar Not Accept The One Ring If It Were Sent Over Sea?

    ANSWER: I received the following lengthy, thoughtful question in December 2025:

    In the Council of Elrond, when taking the Ring to Valinor for destruction/safekeeping/whatever is brought up, Elrond says the Valar wouldn’t take it and Gandalf says that it’s their (the peoples of M.E.) problem to solve for all time anyway. […]

    https://middle-earth.xenite.org/why-would-the-valar-not-accept-the-one-ring-if-it-were-sent-over-sea/
  4. Q: Why Would The Valar Not Accept The One Ring If It Were Sent Over Sea?

    ANSWER: I received the following lengthy, thoughtful question in December 2025:

    In the Council of Elrond, when taking the Ring to Valinor for destruction/safekeeping/whatever is brought up, Elrond says the Valar wouldn’t take it and Gandalf says that it’s their (the peoples of M.E.) problem to solve for all time anyway. […]

    https://middle-earth.xenite.org/why-would-the-valar-not-accept-the-one-ring-if-it-were-sent-over-sea/
  5. Q: Why Would The Valar Not Accept The One Ring If It Were Sent Over Sea?

    ANSWER: I received the following lengthy, thoughtful question in December 2025:

    In the Council of Elrond, when taking the Ring to Valinor for destruction/safekeeping/whatever is brought up, Elrond says the Valar wouldn’t take it and Gandalf says that it’s their (the peoples of M.E.) problem to solve for all time anyway. […]

    https://middle-earth.xenite.org/why-would-the-valar-not-accept-the-one-ring-if-it-were-sent-over-sea/