#procraft — Public Fediverse posts
Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #procraft, aggregated by home.social.
-
One of my enduring fantasies which has only grown in urgency over the past year is to develop and launch a software product (100% handcrafted of course) which ends up making enough money that I can pay other creators for their real work.
Copywriters.
Illustrators.
Video producers.
Translators.
Icon designers.
Nothing would make me happier than to promote a sustainable #ProCraft ecosystem by putting my own money where my mouth is.
I wonder what I could do to take the first step on this…
-
AI-Free is a core value overriding all other values
Something I’ve been thinking about a lot lately is how upsetting it is to have to choose between competing core values. But part of that upset is the liminal space of not knowing which values will win in the end. It’s less of a heartbreak once you’ve made a firm decision and stick with it.
And I have. I place AI-Free above all other core values in terms of which projects & communities I will invest my time & resources in. What I mean by this is, as a Pro-Craft advocate, I can only invest in projects & communities which also promote Pro-Craft policies. In practical terms, this means:
- I will stop using applications riddled with “AI” and find alternatives that do not promote the dangerous proliferation of LLMs.
- I will not participate in software ecosystems which promote the dangerous proliferation of LLMs. I will seek out new ones. I will learn new languages or frameworks, or write my own if necessary.
- I will unfollow people on social media who routinely promote the dangerous proliferation of LLMs, and I will seek out others who value AI-Free solutions & creative practices.
- I will support community movements and political candidates/parties which prioritize crackdowns and strict legislation of Generative AI-based technologies.
- I will repeatedly and without hesitation speak out against the dangerous proliferation of LLMs even when & where it’s unpopular to do so.
- My loyalty to any creator, company, pundit, toolmaker, or software project—while extremely important as I am typically a very loyal person—is ultimately secondary to my loyalty to the Pro-Craft revolution.
I have already lost job opportunities and crossed swords with associates on matters such as these. It is indeed a grim scenario. But I will not back down from my life’s core value in 2026 and beyond. As far as I’m concerned, the fight against the dangerous proliferation of LLMs is a fight on par with the fight to ban assault rifles, the fight for smoking bans in public places (which have by and large been won, thank god), the fight to dismantle nuclear arsenals, the fight to create car-free urban spaces and promote green transport, and many other generational fights for a better future.
I know some people only see arguments of utility. “But I use XYZ LLMs and it’s made my life better! Therefore I will continue to use them!” I’m sorry, but I do not accept the validity of that argument and never will. There are many technologies throughout history which offer great utility, yet the way they are manufactured or distributed or the impact they have on society as a whole are so destructive, the claim of utility is rendered immaterial. In other words: I do not care how useful LLMs are to you. I really don’t. The technology is bad and you should stop using it. And furthermore the onus is not on me to convince you it’s bad, the onus is on you to defend why you believe the utility you are provided is somehow able to override the net negative effect on our planet of said technology.
Good luck trying.
So that’s where we are, as 2026 kicks off. I’m grateful that I’m not alone. A rapidly growing cohort of “rebels” are saying enough is enough. The brand value of “Generative AI” is going down the toilet. Companies and creators are routinely on the offensive to explain why they are promoting slop. Consumers hate it. Increasingly, outrage and boycotts are proving effective. And even as tech leaders are pumping forth the utter B.S. that coding is outmoded, experienced programmers are fighting back with policies that only handwritten code is acceptable in software projects and PRs. May those trends greatly accelerate over the next few moths even as the AI bubble bursts spectacularly.
I wish you all well during this economic turmoil. Even though I wish for the bubble to burst, I do not at all relish the idea of a financial crash. Perhaps the bubble will “slowly implode” instead. No matter what though, challenging times are ahead. Know that I stand with you, shoulder-to-shoulder, fighting for the rights of workers to work and artists to create their art, free from disturbance by the slop machines.
Unite! ✊
–J
https://humansare.social/c/ai_free/p/4030/ai-free-is-a-core-value-overriding-all-other-values
-
Episode 9 of Vibe Coded: Brace Yourselves! (The Crash is Imminent)
The state of play in late 2025 and my expectation that the bubble will burst in 2026. The “Agentic Age” did not materialize this year. Anti-AI activism is heating up…people are noping the f out of the Torment Nexus . Gen-Z and Gen Alpha are turning against the slop machines. That’s AI! goes the new lingo. Microsoft’s AI CEO is getting pummeled online and a post-Windows PC landscape looking increasingly likely. This and a whole lot more, right here on Vibe Coded.
-
"The tools got easier. The job got harder. But for people willing to focus on what actually matters—understanding humans and building things they genuinely want—this is the best time ever to build something meaningful.”
https://www.antonsten.com/articles/how-to-stand-out-when-anyone-can-build-anything/
-
🎙️ New #podcast drop! 🎉
The same tired, clichéd arguments keep coming up over and over again why we should all welcome our new robot overlords, so I'm here to knock 'em all down and push back systematically…but most importantly, make the case for the #ProCraft Movement and how vital it is that we preserve and champion the historical & emotional components of Human Creativity.
🎧 Listen:
https://vibecoded.transistor.fm/8💬 Discuss:
https://humansare.social/post/182 -
Oh wow, I just recorded an *epic* episode of Vibe Coded that will be going out tomorrow, and it's only Part 1 in a series! 😲
I will be systematically demolishing all of the stupid clichéd arguments used by the sloppeddlers & promptfondlers, and in the process extolling the #ProCraft movement where we fight to preserve and champion the historical & emotional components of Human Creativity.
Please subscribe so you don't miss this first episode, going out tomorrow! ☺️
-
Terrific Tools Thursday
Oh yeah, it's TTT time: let's share some terrific tools which we're reasonably sure are free of the sloppy stuff. Anything Top of mind? Tickle your fancy? Take hold of your attention?
#ProCraft #NaturalIntelligence
https://humansare.social/post/36 -
Terrific Tools Thursday – August 21
-
It's GAME DAY! 👏🎉🥳
I'm pleased to announce the launch of the Human Web Collective.
It is a #fediverse social web forum, powered by #PieFed, with the express goal of promoting #ProCraft tools, services, and creators who believe in an ecosystem for the humans, by the humans.
The power lies with we, the people. Rather than simply complain about the bait-and-switch of digital media morphing into the Torment Nexus, let's build our alternative!
Welcome to the Resistance. 😎
-
@ChrisPirillo ngl, this is disappointing. I remember you from the Lockergnome days! To me, the choice is clear. Either we have a bottom-up, grassroots, open web where real artisans and domain experts and community organizers have a fighting chance to stand up to oligarchy and fascism, or we embrace Big Tech's Torment Nexus 3000 (aka genAI). There's little middle ground here, and I'm sad you are simply parroting their talking points.
As a #ProCraft activist, I guess I'm the guy you're mocking.
-
One of the things we need to grapple with in the #ProCraft movement is how certain people who have long been seen as "elder statespeople" in their respective creative fields can get radicalized by anti-craft, anti-humanist tech movements.
The hijacking of language is particularly troubling to me. The idea that you can "create" by typing in a prompt and receive algorithmic artifacts which you then label "art" is truly an extremist position.
We have a long road ahead to recalibrate the debate.
-
@svoisen "it’s clearly the momentum of things for the entire industry"
Programming is not a popularity contest, never has been. I fail to grasp why a particular tech which gets adopted by a fair number of people amounts to a hill of beans when it comes to any discussion of "should".
If we in the #ProCraft movement who eschew any use of LLMs on moral grounds are in a minority, so what? I will never stop advocating for the *human* craft of programming and what ought to be—"momentum" be damned.
-
One of the reasons it's so important to counter the outrageous hype of today's Big Tech industry and the complicit, enabling media is because *we care about the truth*.
Rosey marketing about a product is one thing. You can stretch the truth a little bit, omit the less appealing details—and it can still overall be basically accurate.
Then there's outright lies, deceit, manipulation, and psychotic predictions which are detached from reality! 🤨
We in the #ProCraft movement care about true facts.
-
We Need to Talk About Anti-Web Coding Assistants
It's time. We can't ignore this massive threat to the continuing health of this platform we all love.
@vale has done a deep dive into what the bots think is the state-of-the-art of #WebDev and…uh, it's alarming. 😬
We can, *and we must*, expect better of the tools being thrust in our faces as the future of “whatever”.
#ProCrafthttps://thathtml.blog/2025/02/we-need-to-talk-about-anti-web-coding-assistants/
-
Generative AI maximalism, and 21st-century fascism, are joined at the hip. I've been saying this. I'll keep saying it.
At the same time, we need democracy-loving progressives and the #ProCraft movement to be similarly in alignment. The goals are the same: a decidedly pro-humanist & pro-social justice worldview.
https://tldr.nettime.org/@tante/113990653005125501 -
Hey Thought Leaders™, here’s the bare minimum you could do to meet #ProCraft movement half-way…
Just admit your #generativeAI slop tools are simply that: (optional!) tools. “Some people might find them helpful some of the time” is an argument I could at least respect, even if we still have copious ethical dilemmas.
But cut the crap with the insane rhetoric about how this is “the future of everything” ‼️
Also, a new term: Slop Leaders. You heard it here first! 😊
#blog 🔗 https://jaredwhite.com/20250208/hey-generative-slop-thought-leaders
-
@thisismissem “After 12 years of coding, I’d somehow become worse at my own craft”
Bingo. And that's why the #ProCraft movement needs to fight this dangerous technology with everything we've got.
(Alas I can't agree with the author when they say this: “I’m not suggesting we abandon AI tools—that ship has sailed.” Personally, I'm waiting for the ship to sink right into the ocean.)
-
I swear I didn't read this article earlier, but it certainly is the right timing.
“2025 may be marked less by clashes with Proud Boys marching through the streets, and more by local communities banding together to stop AI infrastructure projects.”
“The oligarchs want a king. Let’s give them a peasants’ revolt instead.” ✊
https://itsgoingdown.org/good-night-tech-right-pull-the-plug-on-ai-fascism/
-
If you think the rise of MAGA & Trumpism is one thing, and the rise of Big Tech AI is a separate thing, you're mistaken.
**They're the same thing.**
A hollowing out of facts, truth, expertise, craft, art, love, and meaning.
It's a deeply *anti-humanist* ideology, one that values might over right and promotes ends-justify-means policy.
So in the end, if you think we're arguing over particular algorithms, companies, or parties, no.
We're waging a war for the very soul of humanity. #ProCraft
-
Reposting this so I can add the hashtag #ProCraft
This toot went viral for a reason: I think a global conversation on the nature of craft, what it means te be a craftsperson, and how we protect ourselves from anti-craft capitalism, is *long overdue* in the digital age.
Share your #ProCraft stories! And let's promote ways our movement can be a positive one, and not merely an anti-AI protest.
https://indieweb.social/@jaredwhite/113828749600843738 -
One more comment: I have very little faith left in existing organizations which steward these considerations.
The OSI
The FSF
What have they done to prevent the enshittification of the Internet, strip-mined en masse by Big Tech, as well as the explosive growth of the far-right?
Nothing. That's what.
*But Jared, that's not their job!*
OK. So whose job is it then?!
-
And before someone wanders into my mentions to say that technology is neutral and ethical considerations don't belong in software licenses, blah blah blah…
…well you're wrong. 😄
-
I'm likely going to be working on a major new installable software project later this year, and I'm very unsure I want to release it under an #OpenSource license as they are currently defined.
What I want is a combination of an #EthicalSource license such as Do No Harm (which unfortunately seems to have stalled in its development 3 years ago), combined with a #ProCraft clause which forbids using the software to promote or train LLMs.
I simply refuse to release code usable by LLM-loving Nazis.