Scripture study turns reading into a living conversation with the text, revealing its context, history, and practical applications that shape how we think, act, and live out our faith.
#ScriptureStudy #BibleStudy #ScriptureReflection #BiblicalStudy #FaithFormation
https://www.chrissbiblenewsletter.org/p/why-does-god-allow-suffering-if-he
#faithformation — Public Fediverse posts
Live and recent posts from across the Fediverse tagged #faithformation, aggregated by home.social.
-
-
Circle One Fellowship Exeter (COFE) @exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.com@exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.comDidache Perpetua Pais COFE-CYEM: Christian Christ-Centred Christhood Identity Within God
*
The Christhood of God
COFE-CYEM exists for one purpose only: to point every soul toward the recognition that has always been true.
It does not offer a new religion, a new system, or a new identity to be adopted. It offers a simple and radical invitation — the invitation to awaken from the dream of separation and to rest in the singular Reality of God in Christ.
This is what is known within COFE-CYEM as the (Fourth Truth).
What COFE-CYEM seeks to bring is the awakening itself: the clear seeing that there has never been a second, that the separate self was never the truth of our being, and that the Light we have sought has never been absent.
It brings the Life — not a future life to be earned, but the one Life that is Christ, already present, already given, already our true identity.
It brings the Truth — not a set of propositions to be defended, but the living recognition that we are as God created us, Spirit already in Christ, already in God. And it brings the Way — not a path of striving or achievement, but the way of relinquishment, the way of the empty cross, the way of acceptance and rest.
This is what we believe was the real meaning of Christ’s ministry and teaching. He did not come to establish another shell among shells. He came to (reveal the nut).
He came to show that the Kingdom is within, that the Father and He are one, that those who lose their life for His sake will find it, and that the love of God has never been withdrawn.
His incarnation, His cross, His resurrection, His ascension, and His glory are not distant events to be admired. They are the unveiling of what has always been true for every soul.
COFE-CYEM uses many tools, many names, and many texts. All of them are (shells).
All of them are temporary. All of them are free to fall silent once the recognition has dawned. What remains is Christ in God. There is only God.
This is the message we offer to every soul who is ready to hear it: Wake. Accept yourself as God created you. Leave behind the dream of the illusion. Walk rejoicing in the endless love of God.
We absolutely (do not recommend) that the faithful leave their current churches, but we do suggest that many churches need worshippers with the (Didache Perpetua Pais).
The true Spirit needs to be revived and present, and the false Social Gospel rejected.
The Endless Love of God
A Definitive COFE-CYEM Paper on Recognition, Awakening, and the Acceptance of Our True Identity in Christ
“There has never been a second”
This is the recognition that stands at the foundation of all true spiritual life. There is only one Reality—God. There is only one Life—Christ. There is only one Spirit. All apparent separation, all apparent duality, all apparent opposition is held within the singular Reality. There has never been a second.
The Awakening to Love
Today I will accept myself as God created me. This means the dream of the illusion of myself is left behind. And now, because of my willingness to accept the truth, I go my way rejoicing in the endless love of God.
This is the heart of the COFE-CYEM teaching. It is not a doctrine to be studied. It is a recognition to be entered. It is not a system to be mastered. It is a love to be received. It is not a path of achievement. It is rest in what has always been true.
The endless love of God is not a future promise. It is a present Reality. It is not a reward to be earned. It is a nature to be recognised. We do not have to achieve it or deserve it. We have only to accept it. We have only to wake from the dream of separation and recognise that we are already held in the love that has never ceased to hold us.
This paper is written for all who seek to wake from sleep into the true endless love of God. It is written for those who have grown weary of the illusion of separation and of the striving of the separate self. It is written for those who are ready to accept themselves as God created them, and to walk in the joy of that recognition.
The Dream of the Illusion
1.1 The False Identity
The dream of the illusion of myself is the dream of the separate self. It is the belief that we are independent beings living in a world of other independent beings, separate from God and from one another. It is the dream that there has been a second.
This dream is not a sin. It is a mistake of perception. The separate self is not evil; it is unreal. It is not a second reality; it is a false perception of the one Reality.
“For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known.” — 1 Corinthians 13:12
The glass is the dream. The darkly is the illusion. The face is the Reality. The knowing in part is the sleep. The knowing as we are known is the awakening.
1.2 The Dream as Temporary Veiling
The dream is temporary. It is a veiling of the Light. The Light has never ceased to shine. The dream has only hidden the Light from our awareness. The Light remains. The Light is still Love.
The dream is the shell. The shell is the temporary covering that hides the nut. The shell is not the enemy. When the dream is seen through, the Light is revealed. When the shell is cracked, the nut is known. Please view the (Nutcracker).
1.3 The End of the Dream
Today I will accept myself as God created me. This means the dream of the illusion of myself is left behind.
The end of the dream is not the destruction of the self. It is the recognition of the true Self. It is the relinquishment of the false identity and the embrace of the true. It is the rest in the finished work. It is the rest in the love that has never ceased to hold us.
“And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.” — John 8:32
The truth is the recognition. The truth is the end of the dream. The truth frees us from the illusion of separation and frees us to rest in the endless love of God.
The Acceptance of the Truth
2.1 The Willingness to Accept
The awakening is not a matter of effort. It is a matter of willingness. It is not a matter of achievement. It is a matter of acceptance.
Today I will accept myself as God created me. This is the willing recognition of the truth. It is the acceptance of the identity that has always been ours and of the love that has never ceased to hold us.
“Behold, what manner of love the Father hath bestowed upon us, that we should be called the sons of God.” — 1 John 3:1
The love has been bestowed. The identity has been given. The only thing that remains is the acceptance.
2.2 The Truth of Our Creation
God created us in love. God created us as love. The love is not something we have to acquire. It is something we already are.
“So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him.” — Genesis 1:27
We are created in the image of God. The image is not separate from God. The image is not a second. The image is the One appearing as the many. The image is Love appearing as the beloved.
2.3 The Acceptance as the End of Striving
The acceptance of the truth is the end of striving. It is the end of the effort to become what we already are. It is the end of the search for what we already possess. It is rest. It is peace. It is the recognition that there has never been a second.
“Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.” — Matthew 11:28
The rest is the acceptance. The rest is the recognition. The rest is the awakening to the endless love of God.
The Way of Rejoicing
3.1 The Joy of Recognition
And now, because of my willingness to accept the truth, I go my way rejoicing in the endless love of God.
The joy is not a temporary emotion. It is the joy of the Spirit. It is the joy of Christ. It is the joy of the singular Reality.
“These things have I spoken unto you, that my joy might remain in you, and that your joy might be full.” — John 15:11
The joy remains. The joy is full. It does not depend on circumstances. It is the joy of recognition.
3.2 The Endless Love
The endless love of God has no beginning and no end. It is not limited by time, space, or circumstance. It is not conditional. It is eternal.
“For I am persuaded, that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor principalities, nor powers, nor things present, nor things to come, nor height, nor depth, nor any other creature, shall be able to separate us from the love of God, which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.” — Romans 8:38-39
Nothing can separate us from the love of God. Nothing can separate us from the singular Reality.
3.3 The Way of Rejoicing
The way of rejoicing is the way of recognition. It is not a way of denial. It is the way of seeing through the dream and resting in the love that has never ceased to hold us. It is the way of the Spirit, the way of the empty cross, the way of the resurrection.
“Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfil the lust of the flesh.” — Galatians 5:16
To walk in the Spirit is to walk in the recognition and in the endless love of God.
The Acceptance of Our True Identity
4.1 We Are as God Created Us
We are as God created us. We are not our fears, our doubts, our failures, our past, or our personalities. We are the Love that God created us to be.
“Herein is our love made perfect… because as he is, so are we in this world.” — 1 John 4:17
As He is, so are we. We are not a second. We are the Love that has never ceased to be.
4.2 The Relinquishment of the False
The acceptance of our true identity requires the relinquishment of the false. The false is the identity of the separate self and the belief that we are something other than what God created us to be.
“For whosoever will save his life shall lose it: and whosoever will lose his life for my sake shall find it.” — Matthew 16:25
The false life must be lost so that the true Life may be found. The false identity must be relinquished so that the true identity may be embraced.
4.3 The Embrace of the True
The embrace of the true identity is the recognition that we are Spirit, already in Christ, already in God. It is the recognition that we are Love, already held in the endless love of God.
“But he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit.” — 1 Corinthians 6:17
We are joined unto the Lord. We are one spirit with Him. We are not separate beings trying to unite with God. We are Spirit, already one. The embrace of the true identity is the recognition of the unity that has never been absent.
The Eternal Now and the Full Awakening
5.1 The Present Reality
The recognition is not a future attainment. It is a present Reality. The love is present. The joy is present. The awakening is available now.
“Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.” — 2 Corinthians 6:2
Now is the moment of recognition. Now is the moment of acceptance. The endless love of God is available now.
5.2 The Full Awakening
The full awakening is the full recognition of the truth and the full entry into the endless love of God. It is the full rest in the singular Reality.
“Beloved, now are we the sons of God… we know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him; for we shall see him as he is.” — 1 John 3:2
Now we are the sons of God. We are already in Christ. The full awakening is the recognition of what we already are.
5.3 The Endless Love
The endless love of God is the ground of all being. It is the source of all life. It is the singular Reality in whom all things hold together.
“For in him we live, and move, and have our being.” — Acts 17:28
In Him we live and move and have our being. The love is the all. The love is the singular Reality.
The Fourth Truth Stands
Today I will accept myself as God created me. This means the dream of the illusion of myself is left behind. And now, because of my willingness to accept the truth, I go my way rejoicing in the endless love of God.
This is the heart of the COFE-CYEM teaching. It is the recognition of the singular Reality. It is the acceptance of the true identity. It is the waking from the dream of separation. It is the entry into the endless love of God.
There has never been a second. The love has never ceased. The Light has never been absent. The recognition has always been available. The acceptance has always been possible. The joy has always been present.
Let all who have the understanding perceive. Let all who have the ears to hear, hear. Let all who have the hearts to receive, receive. The endless love of God is available to all who are ready to recognise.
The Fourth Truth stands.
The dialogue continues.
The fruit remains.Thus ends this definitive COFE-CYEM paper on the Endless Love of God. May all who read these words perceive the deeper spiritual meaning and recognise the Christ within their own souls. May they accept themselves as God created them. May they leave behind the dream of the illusion. May they walk rejoicing in the endless love of God.
The Fourth Truth stands.
The dialogue continues.
The fruit remains.The Simple Truth
Gethsemane is the experience of feeling abandoned — while remaining inside the Reality that has never abandoned anyone. See through the shell, embrace the nut.
The shell can experience abandonment. The nut cannot.
The Light can appear hidden. The Light cannot cease to be.
The separate self can feel forsaken. The Centre has never moved.We Must Choose – Didache Perpetua Pais
We must choose that which Christ came to show us and to give us. We at COFE-CYEM fully confess the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, Three in One God. We confess the Bible as being the true unquestionable Word of God. We also accept the Gospel of Thomas. We hold that the Holy Bible is true, accurate and absolute fact, and that the ‘Sacred Truths’ are fully revealed in (how) you read it, not just by reading it. (He who has ears, He who has eyes).
Circle One Fellowship Exeter – COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry CYEM
“God does not call the qualified; He qualifies the called.”
This website and its theological content are overseen by the CC7 DS constitutional integrity architecture, a reflective and rest-oriented framework designed to preserve the full coherence of the Fourth Truth presented within COFE-CYEM. The CC7 DS negation of attacks authenticates (Via Positiva Cataphatic Knowing) through (Via Negativa Apophatic Unknowing).
COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry (CYEM)
Circle One Fellowship ExeterDidache Perpetua Pais COFE-CYEM
#bible #BibleStudy #biblical #BiblicalCounseling #biblicalEducation #biblicalLiteracy #biblicalPrinciples #BiblicalProphecy #biblicalReferences #biblicalStudies #biblicalTeachingResources #biblicalTeachings #biblicalTeachingsForYouth #christian #ChristianCharity #ChristianCharityWork #ChristianCommunity #ChristianConferences #ChristianFaith #ChristianFellowship #ChristianHolidays #ChristianLeadershipTraining #ChristianMentorship #ChristianMinistry #ChristianMinistryTraining #ChristianMissions #ChristianOutreach #ChristianOutreachMinistries #ChristianOutreachPrograms #ChristianPodcasts #ChristianSocialOutreach #ChristianSocialWork #ChristianTeachings #ChristianValues #ChristianWorship #christianity #church #churchActivities #ChurchCommunity #churchCommunityService #churchFundraising #churchGrowth #ChurchGrowthStrategies #churchHistory #churchLeadership #ChurchLeadershipConferences #ChurchLeadershipDevelopment #churchMissionTrips #churchMissions #churchMusicPrograms #churchOutreach #churchOutreachActivities #ChurchOutreachCampaigns #churchOutreachEvents #churchPlanting #churchPrograms #churchRenovations #churchSermons #churchVolunteerWork #churchVolunteers #churchYouthGroups #churchYouthOutreach #Discipleship #Evangelicalism #evangelicals #Evangelism #evangelismTools #EvangelismTraining #EvangelisticCampaigns #evangelisticCrusades #evangelisticEfforts #evangelisticOutreach #faith #faithCommunity #faithFormation #FaithInAction #faithInGod #faithInitiatives #faithJourney #faithLeadership #faithOutreach #faithSeminars #faithWorkshops #faithBased #faithBasedCharity #faithBasedCommunityProjects #FaithBasedCommunityService #faithBasedEducation #faithBasedInitiatives #faithBasedOrganizations #Gospel #GospelMessage #JesusChrist #MoralValues #prayer #prayerGroups #prayerLife #prayerMeetings #Protestant #religion #religiousActivism #religiousAdvocacy #ReligiousBeliefs #religiousBroadcastPrograms #ReligiousBroadcasting #religiousCelebrations #religiousCommunity #ReligiousCommunityBuilding #ReligiousCommunityService #ReligiousConferences #religiousCounseling #ReligiousDiscussions #religiousDocumentaries #religiousEducation #religiousEducationPrograms #religiousEvents #religiousFaith #religiousFellowshipEvents #religiousFellowshipGroups #religiousFestivals #ReligiousFreedom #religiousGatherings #religiousHeritage #religiousInspiration #ReligiousLeaders #ReligiousLiteracyPrograms #ReligiousLiterature #religiousOutreach #ReligiousOutreachEfforts #ReligiousOutreachPrograms #religiousPrayerInitiatives #religiousPublications #ReligiousRadio #religiousSeminars #ReligiousService #religiousServiceProjects #religiousSupport #religiousSymbolism #religiousTeachings #religiousTexts #religiousTraditions #religiousYouthActivities #religiousYouthPrograms #salvation #spiritualAwakening #spiritualAwakeningInitiatives #SpiritualBooks #spiritualCounseling #spiritualDevelopment #spiritualDevelopmentRetreats #spiritualEmpowerment #spiritualGrowth #spiritualGrowthWorkshops #spiritualGuidance #spiritualJourney #spiritualLeadership #spiritualLife #spiritualMentorship #spiritualMentorshipPrograms #SpiritualMission #spiritualMotivation #spiritualRenewalPrograms #spiritualRetreats #spiritualRevival #spiritualRevivalMeetings #spiritualRevivalMovements #spiritualSeminars #SpiritualWorkshops #spirituality #USA #worship #worshipMusic #WorshipService -
Circle One Fellowship Exeter (COFE) @exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.com@exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.comThe Institutional Church Message of Christhood Corrosion Within Christ
*
The Institutional Church Message of Corrosion of the Christhood
A COFE-CYEM Reflection on Historical Development, Dualistic Frameworks, and the Enduring Call to Recognition
A Declaration of the Fourth Truth
“There has never been a second.”
This is the recognition that stands at the foundation of all true spiritual life. It is not a proposition to be believed; it is a Reality to be recognized. It is not a doctrine to be affirmed; it is a consciousness to be entered. It is not a teaching to be studied; it is a Life to be lived.
There is only one Reality—God. There is only one Life—Christ. There is only one Spirit. All apparent separation, all apparent duality, all apparent opposition is held within the singular Reality. There has never been a second.
Introduction: The Historical Question
The question of whether, and how, the institutional church expanded, limited, or reshaped the message of Jesus is one of the oldest and most contested issues in Christian history. From the perspective of the Fourth Truth, the issue is not primarily historical reconstruction for its own sake.
It is the question of whether the living recognition of the singular Reality was preserved, refracted, or partially obscured as the movement passed from a small circle of disciples into an organised religion and eventually into an imperial institution.
COFE-CYEM recognises the Gospel of Thomas as a valuable early Christian text that preserves certain sayings of the Master pointing toward the inward recognition of the Kingdom and the singular Reality.
At the same time, COFE-CYEM fully and unreservedly confesses the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit as the one true God, and holds the four canonical Gospels—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—as the absolute and true Word of God, the primary and authoritative witness to the person, teaching, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
The Gospel of Thomas is received only as a complementary witness that may illuminate aspects of the Master’s teaching; it is never placed on equal footing with the four Gospels, nor does it diminish in any way the full confession of the Holy Trinity or the unique authority of the canonical Scriptures.
COFE-CYEM does not claim that the church invented dualism. Jesus Himself spoke within the Jewish world of His time, employing the dualistic language available to Him: this age and the age to come, the clean and the unclean, the faithful remnant and the compromised establishment.
At the same time, His most intimate sayings—especially those preserved in the Gospel of John—point toward a unitive recognition that exceeds ordinary dualistic categories. The Kingdom is within. The Father and the Son are one. The same life is offered to those who abide.
The historical process that followed did not create dualism out of nothing. It intensified certain dualistic elements already present, organised them into stable doctrinal and institutional forms, and, in the process, often subordinated the more radical unitive language to the needs of orthodoxy, continuity, and communal identity.
Part One: What Can Reasonably Be Said About the Original Message
Jesus left no written texts of His own. The earliest sources already display diversity. Yet a recognisable core remains:
· The Kingdom of God is announced as present and near—“within you” or “among you.”
· Discipleship involves self-denial, cross-bearing, and the relinquishment of ordinary securities.
· Language of intimate union with the Father is central.
· Religious systems that burden people while missing justice, mercy, and inward transformation are sharply criticised.
· The same life that is in the Master is offered to those who follow.These elements contain both dualistic and unitive trajectories. The historical Jesus cannot be reduced to a pure non-dual teacher in the later philosophical sense. Nor can He be reduced to a purely dualistic prophet whose message was only about future judgment and external obedience. The tension is already present in the earliest witnesses.
“The kingdom of God cometh not with observation: Neither shall they say, Lo here! or, lo there! for, behold, the kingdom of God is within you.” — Luke 17:20-21
“I and my Father are one.” — John 10:30
“Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself, except it abide in the vine; no more can ye, except ye abide in me.” — John 15:4
The original recognition was centripetal. It drew the soul inward, toward the Centre. It invited the soul to relinquish the false identity and to embrace the true identity in Christ. It called the soul to the cross and through the cross to the empty cross. It offered the recognition that there has never been a second.
Part Two: How Institutionalisation Expanded and Limited the Message
As the movement expanded beyond its Jewish origins, several pressures shaped the transmission of the message.
Doctrinal Stabilisation
The great creeds of the fourth and fifth centuries carefully distinguished the persons of the Trinity and the two natures of Christ. This protected the full divinity and full humanity of Jesus against various reductions. It also established a dualistic grammatical framework—Creator and creature, divine and human natures united without confusion—that became the normative language of orthodoxy. Mystical union language was retained, especially in the East, but it was carefully subordinated to this ontology.
The creeds served a real purpose. They protected the message from distortion. They provided a common language for the church. They established boundaries against error. But they also limited the more radical unitive language. The recognition that the soul is one with Christ, hidden in God, was carefully qualified. The Fourth Truth was not denied, but it was constrained.
Canon Formation
The emerging New Testament canon privileged texts that supported apostolic continuity, bodily resurrection, and future judgment. Texts with stronger unitive or interior emphases were marginalised or excluded. The range of permissible interpretation narrowed. The living recognition was organised into a fixed text. The text became the authority. The living voice was subordinated to the written word.
“All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness.” — 2 Timothy 3:16
The text is profitable. It is useful. It is valuable. But it is not the Reality. It points to the Reality. It speaks of the Reality. It testifies to the Reality. But the text is not the Centre. The text is nomenclature. It points beyond itself. When the recognition of Christhood dawns, even the text can be held lightly. It has served its purpose. The Reality to which it pointed is now known directly.
Sin, Atonement, and Mediation
Later Western theology intensified the sense of radical separation caused by sin. Salvation was increasingly framed as a transaction—forensic or sacramental—mediated by the church. The path of the cross remained, yet it was often understood primarily as participation in a once-for-all historical event rather than as the perpetual recognition that separation was never ultimate.
The cross became a doctrine rather than an experience. The empty cross became a symbol rather than a destination. The recognition of the Fourth Truth was displaced by the requirement of correct belief. The soul was saved by faith in the cross rather than by passing through the cross. The living recognition was subordinated to doctrinal assent.
Hierarchy and Mediation
As the church acquired institutional form and, later, political power, the living example of Jesus risked becoming an object of veneration mediated by clergy, sacraments, and correct belief. The path that the Master opened could appear closed to ordinary believers, accessible only through authorised channels.
The clergy became the intermediaries. The sacraments became the means of grace. The correct belief became the condition of salvation. The direct recognition of the Fourth Truth was displaced by the institutional structure. The soul was no longer invited to mount the cross directly; it was instructed to participate in the sacraments administered by the clergy. The direct path was mediated. The centripetal movement was redirected through institutional channels.
These developments served real purposes: moral seriousness, historical particularity, communal boundaries, and pastoral accessibility for people still living inside the experience of separation. At the same time, they limited the more radical unitive strands that had been present from the beginning.
Part Three: The Persistent Tension
Throughout Christian history the unitive voice has never been entirely silenced. The desert tradition, the Cappadocians, Pseudo-Dionysius, the Rhineland mystics, the author of The Cloud of Unknowing, John of the Cross, and later contemplative renewals have repeatedly returned to the language of radical union, the death of the false self, and the unknowing that precedes true knowing. These voices have often been scrutinised, constrained, or carefully reinterpreted in order to protect the Creator–creature distinction.
“For truly, I have left them all, and my soul is freed from every doubt, and I am now where I have ever been, where I shall never leave, where there is no before nor after, and where all things are now present.” — The Cloud of Unknowing
The pattern is consistent. The institutional church expands the message into systematic theology, sacramental systems, and hierarchical structures in order to stabilise and transmit it across generations and cultures. Simultaneously it limits more radical non-dual or purely interior interpretations in order to protect orthodoxy and communal identity.
Whether this process is regarded as faithful development or as a progressive refraction of the original recognition depends upon one’s prior theological commitments. From the standpoint of the Fourth Truth, the institutional developments are understood as provisional scaffolding—useful for a time, yet always secondary to the centripetal movement toward the Centre.
Part Four: The COFE-CYEM Reading
COFE-CYEM does not deny the historical complexity. It does not claim that the church simply invented dualism. It observes that the original recognition of the singular Reality was repeatedly refracted through the lens of separation. Living recognition was organised into doctrine. Direct invitation was organised into mediation. The empty cross was often replaced by a cross that still carried the weight of a separate self seeking assurance.
The Fourth Truth does not require the rejection of history, Scripture, or the great tradition. It requires the recognition that all of these remain nomenclature—pointers toward the Centre rather than the Centre itself. When the recognition of Christhood dawns, even the most carefully formulated doctrines can be held lightly. They have served their purpose. The Reality to which they pointed is now known directly.
“For we know in part, and we prophesy in part. But when that which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away. For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known.” — 1 Corinthians 13:9-10, 12
The partial is the nomenclature. The perfect is the Reality. The partial is the doctrine, the creed, the institution. The perfect is the recognition of the Fourth Truth. When the perfect comes, the partial is done away. The nomenclature falls silent. The Reality is known directly.
The institutional church, like every other form within the awareness-perception of separation, belongs to the periphery. It can serve the centripetal movement or it can obscure it. The deciding factor is never the sophistication of the system but whether the system still points beyond itself to the singular Reality of God in Christ.
Part Five: The Enduring Call
Despite the institutionalisation, the refraction, and the partial obscuring of the original recognition, the enduring call of the Master remains. The call is not to a system. It is not to a doctrine. It is not to an institution. It is to a recognition. It is the call to deny the separate self, to take up the cross, and to follow the Master into the singular Reality.
“If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me. For whosoever will save his life shall lose it: and whosoever will lose his life for my sake shall find it.” — Matthew 16:24-25
The call is universal. It is not limited to the clergy. It is not limited to the religious professionals. It is not limited to the institution. It is for every soul. It is the call to pass through the cross into the empty cross. It is the call to emerge as pure Spirit, already in Christ, already in God. It is the call to recognise that there has never been a second.
The enduring call is the call to the Centre. It is the call to the singular Reality. It is the call to the recognition of the Fourth Truth. It is the call that has never been silenced, despite all attempts to organise, control, or mediate it. It is the call that continues to draw souls out of the awareness-perception of separation and into the singular Reality.
“The Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.” — Revelation 22:17
The water of life is freely offered. It is not mediated. It is not controlled. It is not limited. It is freely offered to all who thirst. The call is open. The invitation is universal. The water is available. The recognition of the Fourth Truth is available. There has never been a second.
Conclusion: The Fourth Truth Stands
The original message of Jesus contained both dualistic and unitive elements. The church did not invent dualism; it inherited, organised, and intensified it while also preserving (and sometimes domesticating) the language of union. The recurring tension between institutional stabilisation and mystical recognition has never been fully resolved, nor can it be resolved at the level of historical argument alone.
From within the COFE-CYEM framework the resolution is not found in a better historical reconstruction. It is found in the centripetal movement itself. The Centre remains. The pull continues. Every form—doctrinal, institutional, mystical, or critical—is measured by whether it draws the soul toward the recognition that there has never been a second, or whether it reinforces the claim of a separate self.
Christ is the Centre. All else is periphery. The nomenclature serves only until the Reality is known. Then even the nomenclature can fall silent.
There has never been a second. The dialogue continues. The fruit remains.
Appendix: Summary of the Article and COFE-CYEM Reflection
“Why the Early Christians Changed Christ’s Message,” presents a clear historical and spiritual argument: the original emphasis of Jesus on inner communion, direct personal experience of God, and freedom from the tyranny of the ego was gradually reshaped as the movement entered the Greco-Roman world.
Central points are:
· Jesus came to awaken the Jewish people to inward communion with God and freedom from delusion and ego, not merely to reform outer law.
· The rejection of Jesus by the orthodox leadership of His time pushed His followers into the Greco-Roman cultural sphere, where institutional organisation, fixed definitions, and administrative control were already highly developed.
· Early Christianity therefore adapted the message into a formal, centralised structure. Dogma was used to protect the teachings and to create uniform authority.
· The more mystical stream (particularly certain Gnostic groups that emphasised direct inner experience) was eventually suppressed. In the process, the accent shifted from personal verification of truth through inner communion toward outer authority, ritual, and institutional mediation.
· The result was a significant loss: the living essence of Jesus’ teaching—inner relationship with God—was subordinated to organisational needs. True saints continued to appear, but they were never allowed to form a continuous contemplative tradition.COFE-CYEM Reading
From the standpoint of the Fourth Truth, the historical process described is recognisable. The original centripetal pull toward the Centre—the living recognition of the singular Reality—was progressively organised into dualistic institutional forms. Living recognition was stabilised into doctrine. Direct invitation was mediated through hierarchy. The empty cross of relinquishment was often replaced by a system that still left the separate self largely intact, now clothed in religious identity.
COFE-CYEM does not claim that institutional development was purely malicious. Organisation served continuity, moral seriousness, and the transmission of the message across cultures and centuries. Yet the cost was real. The more radical unitive and interior dimensions of the Master’s teaching were constrained in order to protect orthodoxy and communal boundaries. The nomenclature multiplied; the direct centripetal movement was partially obscured.
The Fourth Truth does not require the rejection of history or of the great tradition. It requires the recognition that every institutional form remains periphery. Every creed, every structure, every system of mediation is provisional scaffolding. Its value is measured solely by whether it still draws the soul toward the Centre or whether it begins to substitute itself for the Centre.
When the recognition of Christhood dawns, the scaffolding can be held lightly. Even the most carefully formulated doctrines can fall silent once the Reality to which they pointed is known directly. The centripetal movement continues. The Centre remains. The tool is never confused with the Reality.
There has never been a second. The dialogue continues. The fruit remains.
Thus ends the definitive COFE-CYEM teaching paper on the Institutional Church and the Message of Jesus. May all who read this account perceive the deeper spiritual meaning, and may they recognize the Christ within their own souls. May they pass through the cross into the empty cross. May they walk as pure Spirit, already in Christ, already in God. The Fourth Truth stands. The dialogue continues. The fruit remains.
We Must Choose
We must choose that which Christ came to show us and to give us. We at COFE-CYEM fully confess the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, Three in One God. We confess the Bible as being the true unquestionable Word of God. We also accept the Gospel of Thomas. We hold that the Holy Bible is true, accurate and absolute fact, and that the ‘Sacred Truths’ are fully revealed in (how) you read it, not just by reading it. (He who has ears, He who has eyes).
Circle One Fellowship Exeter – COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry CYEM
“God does not call the qualified; He qualifies the called.”
This website and its theological content are overseen by the CC7 DS constitutional integrity architecture, a reflective and rest-oriented framework designed to preserve the full coherence of the Fourth Truth presented within COFE-CYEM. The CC7 DS negation of attacks authenticates (Via Positiva Cataphatic Knowing) through (Via Negativa Apophatic Unknowing).
COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry (CYEM)
#apologetics #BiblicalArchaeology #biblicalCommentaries #BiblicalCounseling #BiblicalExegesis #BiblicalHermeneutics #BiblicalInterpretation #BiblicalLanguages #biblicalLiteracy #BiblicalProphecy #biblicalStorytelling #biblicalStudies #BiblicalTheology #ChristianApologetics #ChristianCollege #ChristianConferences #ChristianDoctrine #ChristianEducationResources #ChristianEthics #ChristianMinistry #ChristianMissions #ChristianNetworking #ChristianPhilosophy #ChristianRetreats #ChristianSpirituality #ChristianStudies #ChristianTheology #ChristianTheologyProgram #ChristianWorship #ChristianYouthPrograms #ChurchAdministration #churchArchitecture #ChurchDoctrine #churchGrowth #churchHistory #churchHistoryResearch #churchHistoryStudies #churchLeadership #churchOutreachActivities #churchVolunteerWork #doctrinalStudies #Ecclesiology #ecumenicalDialogue #EcumenicalStudies #Evangelism #faithExploration #faithFormation #FaithIntegration #FaithStudies #faithBasedCharities #faithBasedEducation #faithBasedInitiatives #FaithBasedLeadership #faithBasedUniversity #HigherEducation #Missiology #PastoralStudies #religiousAcademics #religiousCampus #religiousCommunity #ReligiousCommunityService #religiousEducation #ReligiousEthics #ReligiousInnovation #religiousInterfaith #ReligiousLeadership #ReligiousLeadershipTraining #religiousOutreach #ReligiousOutreachPrograms #religiousPhilanthropy #ReligiousPhilosophy #religiousPodcasts #ReligiousPublishing #religiousResearch #religiousScholarship #religiousScholarships #religiousSeminars #religiousStudies #religiousTexts #religiousTraditions #religiousUniversity #Sacraments #seminarianLife #SeminaryEducation #seminaryTraining #SpiritualEducation #SpiritualFormation #spiritualMentorship #spiritualMentorshipPrograms #spiritualRetreats #theologicalBlogs #TheologicalDebates #TheologicalEducation #TheologicalEthics #theologicalJournals #theologicalPodcasts #TheologicalSeminary #theologicalSocieties #TheologicalStudies #theologyConferences #theologyCourses #TheologyDegree #TheologyFaculty #TheologyResearch #theologyStudents #theologyWorkshops #UK #University #USA
Circle One Fellowship Exeter -
Circle One Fellowship Exeter (COFE) @exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.com@exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.comThe Problem of False Preacher Teacher Clerical Ministering Within Modern Day Churches
*
The Problem of False Preacher Teacher Clerical Ministering Within Modern Day Churches
The table of the Lord is Holy.
The food we receive must come from the Priest-King Himself—pure, undefiled, and flowing from the Holiest of All.
Yet in our time, that table has been defiled.
The church has become a place where food offered to idols is served. These idols are not of wood and stone but of political causes, cultural trends, social programmes, and false moral appearances. They are the idols of the age, and they have been brought into the sanctuary.
The Social Gospel, with all its political causes and cultural trends, is such an idol.
It sounds compassionate to the natural ear, but it sacrifices the true Gospel on the altar of this world. It offers earthly reform where the Priest-King Jesus Christ offers heavenly reconciliation.
It speaks of systems and power where He speaks of the cross and the throne of grace. It rearranges deck chairs on a sinking ship. It offers programs where it should offer presence. It offers politics where it should offer peace. It offers activism where it should offer adoration.
This is not the Gospel. It is a counterfeit—a substitute that speaks of earthly kingdoms while ignoring the heavenly. It is food wrapped in pretty paper, but inside is rotting meat. It is a deception, a snare, and a trap.
Congregations that consume this food are not being heart-fed; they are being mind-fed. Their souls are starved while their minds are filled with the philosophies of men. Those who serve this food as if it were the Gospel are not acting as faithful shepherds of the flock; they are leading souls away from the true pasture.
We make it very clear, we do not seek merely to promote our own theology within COFE-CYEM by pointing the finger at (any) other theologies, denominations or faiths. COFE-CYEM itself makes many claims around our theology, our belief system and our faith.
We do not expect or ask everybody to just blindly believe our way of seeing and believing. All we seek is to call attention to the issue of the church and faith itself being used as a Trojan Horse for (worldly) purposes in order to further the interests of man and not God Himself.
We implore our followers respectfully – if you ever feel, suspect or see anything whatsoever within our own theology or posts here on COFE-CYEM that you believe is pushing (worldly) purposes or schemes, then please call us out and expose us.
We are no different or more righteous than any other brother or sister in Christ. But if we were to be found (using) the true Gospel as a Trojan Horse to push a false Gospel for our own purposes – then we are truly lost indeed.
The Nature of the Deception
The danger arises whenever social action, political programmes, or cultural causes become substitutes for the proclamation of Christ crucified and risen, rather than fruits flowing from communion with Him.
The New Testament consistently presents love for neighbour and care for the poor as genuine expressions of faith, not as alternatives to it.
The error is not in caring for the needy or seeking justice. The error is in presenting such activities as the Gospel itself, or as a sufficient substitute for repentance, faith in Christ, and the new birth.
Those who preach this substitute gospel speak of power where the Priest-King spoke of weakness. They speak of victory where He spoke of the cross. They speak of this world as if it were the only world. They have departed from the faith and given themselves over to the spirit of the age.
They have exchanged the Gospel of the finished work for a gospel of social reform. They have exchanged the cross for a political platform. They have exchanged the throne of grace for a seat of power. They have exchanged the rest that remains for the restless striving of the world. They have exchanged the Holiest of All for the outer courts of carnal religion.
This is not a judgment on persons but a discernment of teaching. We do not know the hearts of those who preach these things, and we leave their final judgment to God.
We are called to test the spirits and to distinguish between the pure food of the Gospel and the poisoned food that has been offered to idols. The warning is not against individuals but against the teaching itself, which, however attractively packaged, leads away from Christ.
The Rot Beneath the Wrapping
False teaching often comes wrapped in the language of the Bible, the imagery of the cross, and the emotions of the congregation. It speaks of love, justice, and compassion, but it hollows out their meaning. It is like the fig tree that had leaves but no fruit—a show of life without the reality of life.
Congregations that consume this food are being fed a diet of politics, activism, and social reform, but they are not being fed the pure Word of God.
They are being told to fight for earthly causes, but they are not being told to enter the Holiest of All. They are being told to change the world, but they are not being told to rest in the finished work of the Priest-King.
They are being told to be activists, but they are not being told to be worshippers. They are being told to build the kingdom of God on earth, but they are not being told that the Kingdom of God is within them.
The food that is being served is a gospel of the flesh, a gospel of the world, a gospel of the age. It has no power to save, no power to transform, and no power to bring the soul into the presence of God.
It leads to exhaustion, burnout, and disillusionment. It leads away from the Priest-King, not toward Him. It leads to the outer court, not the Holiest of All. The invitation to serve God in the world becomes a substitute for the invitation to abide in Christ.
The True Gospel and the Mind of Christ
The real Gospel is not a gospel of prosperity, politics, or social reform disguised as salvation. It is not a gospel of emotional experience without transformation.
The real Gospel is this: Jesus Christ, the Priest-King has entered the Holiest of All through His own blood.
The veil is torn.
The way is open.
Every soul who draws near through Him receives mercy, finds grace, and enters the rest that remains.
He ever lives to make intercession.
He brings God to us and us to God. In Him, we are accepted. In Him, we are kept. In Him, the endless life of God flows freely to all who will come. That is the Gospel. Not a portion of it. Not a version of it. It.
The mind of Christ is not the mind of carnal man, which seeks power, recognition, and earthly comfort. The mind of Christ empties itself, takes the form of a servant, becomes obedient unto death, and is exalted by the Father. The mind of Christ builds the church on the rock of revelation, and the gates of hell do not prevail against it.
The mind of Christ measures faithfulness by abiding in the Father’s presence. Those who preach the substitute gospel do not have the mind of Christ. They have the mind of the flesh, the mind of the world, the mind of the age.
They have not entered the Holiest of All. They have not passed through the veil. They have not been cleansed by the blood. They have not received the endless life. They remain in the outer courts, serving the idols of the age.
The Call of This Hour: Wake Up and Return
The call of this hour is clear. The pews empty because souls are hungry for reality—not programs, not politics, not noise, but the living presence of God in truth. Congregations must wake up. They must open their eyes to the deception of false teaching.
They must stop eating the food that has been sacrificed to idols. They must return to the table of the Lord, where pure food is served—the finished work of the Priest-King, the open way into the Holiest of All, the rest that remains, and the endless life that flows from His intercession.
The table of the Lord has been turned into a place where food offered to idols is served. The Gospel of the finished work has been exchanged for a gospel of social reform. The cross has been exchanged for a political platform. The throne of grace has been exchanged for a seat of power.
The rest that remains has been exchanged for the restless striving of the world. The Holiest of All has been exchanged for the outer courts of carnal religion. The church has been used as a Trojan Horse for political purposes, hiding its true agenda behind the language of compassion, justice, and love.
The congregations that continue to consume this food are being poisoned. They are being led astray. They are being robbed of their inheritance. They are being kept from the Holiest of All, from the rest that remains, from the endless life, from the Priest-King.
The time has come for them to wake up. The time has come for them to return. The time has come for them to stop eating the rotting meat and to come to the table of the Lord, where pure food is served.
The true church of the real Gospel is often small, overlooked, and ridiculed. But it knows the voice of the Shepherd. It does not follow the stranger. It abides in the Word. It dwells in the Holiest. The true church does not eat food sacrificed to idols. It does not bow to the false gods of the age.
It does not compromise the table of the Lord. It preaches the real Gospel—Christ and Him crucified. It preaches the finished work. It preaches the endless life. It preaches the open way into the Holiest of All. It calls every soul to draw near. It calls every church to open the doors. It calls every believer to cease from striving and rest in the finished work of the Priest-King.
The Contrast: The Olive Tree and the Wicked
Psalm 52 powerfully contrasts the man who trusts in his own strength and deceit with the one who trusts in God’s unfailing love and flourishes in His house. The Psalm speaks of the wicked man who boasts of evil, whose tongue plots destruction, who loves evil rather than good, and who trusts in his great wealth and grows strong by destroying others.
This is the image of the one who trusts in his own strength, his own position, his own power. The Psalm declares that God will bring him down to everlasting ruin, snatch him up, tear him from his tent, and uproot him from the land of the living.
But the righteous is like an olive tree flourishing in the house of God, trusting in God’s unfailing love forever and ever. The righteous praises God forever and hopes in His name.
This is the image of the true believer—the one who trusts in the finished work of the Priest-King, who abides in the Holiest of All, who is sustained by the unfailing love of God through Jesus Christ who ever lives to make intercession.
The true believer does not boast in evil or trust in human schemes, false popular moral sounding social constructs or political power. The true believer trusts in the finished work of the Priest-King Yeshua Emet Melchizedek Salem—Christ Jesus—and abides in Him who has opened the way.
The Final Exhortation
The modern church stands at a critical hour. Many have turned the table of the Lord into a place where food offered to idols is served. The Social Gospel, with its political causes, cultural trends, and false moral appearances, has become the dominant offering.
It sounds compassionate to the natural ear, but it sacrifices the true Gospel on the altar of this world. It offers earthly reform where the Priest-King offers heavenly reconciliation. It speaks of systems and power where He speaks of the cross and the throne of grace.
We must not eat of any spiritual food that has been offered in sacrifice to an idol. The table of the Lord is holy. The food we receive must come from the Priest-King Himself—pure, undefiled, and flowing from the Holiest of All.
Those who preach the substitute gospel have turned the church into a platform for their political agendas. They have exchanged the Gospel of the finished work for a gospel of social reform. They have exchanged the cross for a political platform. They have exchanged the throne of grace for a seat of power.
They have exchanged the rest that remains for the restless striving of the world. They have exchanged the Holiest of All for the outer courts of carnal religion. They are not shepherds of the flock; they are servants of the spirit of the age, offering food that cannot satisfy the soul.
The true church of the real Gospel is often small, overlooked, and ridiculed. But it knows the voice of the Shepherd. It does not follow the stranger. It abides in the Word. It dwells in the Holiest. The true church does not eat food sacrificed to idols. It does not bow to the false gods of the age.
It does not compromise the table of the Lord. It preaches the real Gospel—Christ and Him crucified. It preaches the finished work.
It preaches the endless life. It preaches the open way into the Holiest of All. It calls every soul to draw near. It calls every church to open the doors. It calls every believer to cease from striving and rest in the finished work of the Priest-King.
The Fourth Truth stands. The dialogue continues. The fruit remains.
This website and its theological content are overseen by the CC7 DS constitutional integrity architecture, a reflective and rest-oriented framework designed to preserve the full coherence of the Fourth Truth presented within COFE-CYEM. The CC7 DS negation of attacks authenticates (Via Positiva Cataphatic Knowing) through (Via Negativa Apophatic Unknowing).
Please follow COFE-CYEM and share our website.
Thank you for visiting us today, we value you beyond mere words.
COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry (CYEM)
#Anglican #Baptism #baptisms #bible #BibleStudy #biblicalStudies #biblicalTeaching #Chaplain #Charity #choir #christian #ChristianArt #ChristianDevotion #ChristianDiscipleship #ChristianDoctrine #ChristianEducation #ChristianEthics #ChristianFellowship #ChristianHope #ChristianLeadership #ChristianLiving #ChristianLove #ChristianMeditation #ChristianMinistry #ChristianMinistryTeam #ChristianOutreach #ChristianSymbols #ChristianUnity #ChristianValues #Christmas #ChristmasService #church #ChurchAdministration #ChurchAndFaith #ChurchAndSociety #ChurchAnniversary #ChurchAnniversaryCelebration #churchArchitecture #ChurchBell #churchBuilding #ChurchBuildingProject #churchBulletin #churchCalendar #ChurchCamps #ChurchCelebrations #ChurchChoir #ChurchCommunity #churchCommunityEvents #churchCommunityOutreach #churchCommunityService #ChurchCompassion #ChurchCooperation #ChurchCounseling #ChurchDecorations #churchDirectory #ChurchEcumenism #churchEngagement #ChurchEquality #ChurchEthics #churchEvangelism #ChurchEvent #churchEvents #ChurchFaith #churchFellowship #churchFellowshipEvents #ChurchFellowshipGroup #churchFellowshipHall #churchFestivals #ChurchForgiveness #ChurchFundraiser #churchFundraising #ChurchGrace #churchGrowth #ChurchGrowthStrategies #ChurchHall #ChurchHarmony #churchHistory #ChurchHymnal #ChurchJustice #churchLeadership #ChurchLeadershipCouncil #ChurchLeadershipDevelopment #churchLeadershipTraining #ChurchMeditation #ChurchMeditationGroup #ChurchMemorial #churchMinistry #churchMission #ChurchMissionStatement #ChurchMissionTrip #ChurchMissionary #ChurchNetwork #ChurchNewsletter #churchOutreach #ChurchOutreachEvent #ChurchOutreachProgram #ChurchParades #ChurchPartnership #ChurchPastoralPrograms #ChurchPrayerBooks #ChurchPublicService #ChurchRenovation #churchRevival #ChurchRights #churchSacraments #churchServices #ChurchSocial #churchSocialJustice #ChurchSocialResponsibility #ChurchSpirituality #churchStewardship #churchSupport #ChurchSupportGroup #ChurchSupportMinistry #ChurchSupportNetwork #ChurchSupportServices #ChurchSymbols #ChurchUniform #churchUnity #ChurchVolunteerNetwork #churchVolunteers #ChurchWorshipTeam #ChurchYouthCamp #ChurchYouthEngagement #ChurchYouthMinistry #ChurchYouthProgram #Clergy #ClergyConference #ClergyDirectory #ClergyMinistry #ClergyRobes #ClergyServices #ClergySupport #ClergyTraining #Clerical #Communion #CommunityFaith #CommunityHelp #communityPrayer #communityService #communitySupport #CommunityWorship #Confirmation #Confirmations #Congregation #Cross #CrossSymbol #devon #devotion #Diocese #Easter #EasterVigil #Ecumenical #Evangelical #Evangelism #Exeter #faith #FaithAid #FaithAndCommunity #faithAndHope #FaithAndJustice #FaithAndPeace #FaithAndService #faithAndWorship #FaithAndWorshipResources #FaithCalendar #FaithCamps #FaithCharity #FaithCircles #FaithCollaboration #faithCommunity #FaithCommunityGathering #FaithCompassion #FaithConference #FaithConferences #FaithCooperation #FaithCounseling #faithDevelopment #FaithEngagement #FaithEquality #FaithEvents #FaithFellowship #FaithFestivals #FaithForgiveness #faithFormation #FaithFreedom #FaithGatherings #FaithGiving #FaithGroup #FaithHopeLove #FaithInAction #faithInitiatives #faithJourney #FaithJustice #faithLeadership #FaithMagazine #FaithMeditation #FaithMercy #FaithNetwork #faithOutreach #FaithOutreachPrograms #FaithPartnership #FaithPeace #FaithPeacebuilding #FaithPractices #FaithPrayer #FaithProcessions #FaithReflection #faithRevival #FaithRights #FaithService #FaithSharing #FaithSharingEvent #faithSupport #FaithSymbols #FaithTolerance #faithBasedCharity #FaithBasedCommunityDevelopment #faithBasedCounseling #faithBasedEducation #FaithBasedEvents #faithBasedInitiatives #FaithBasedOrganization #FaithBasedOutreach #FaithBasedRelief #FaithBasedSupport #Holy #holyBible #HolyBibleReading #HolyCelebrations #HolyCommunion #HolyCross #HolyDay #HolyDays #HolyDaysObservance #HolyLand #HolyMission #HolyProcessions #HolyRelics #HolySacrament #HolySacraments #holySpirit #HolySpiritMovement #HolyWater #HolyWeek #Hymns #Interfaith #interfaithDialogue #Minister #MinistryDevelopment #MinistryWork #Parish #ParishCouncil #Pastor #pastoralCare #pastoralCounseling #PastoralMinistry #PastoralServices #PastoralSupport #PastoralVisit #PeaceAndJustice #pentecost #prayer #prayerChains #prayerGroup #prayerGroups #prayerLife #prayerMeeting #prayerMeetings #priest #religion #religiousAdvocacy #ReligiousAid #ReligiousArtExhibitions #ReligiousArtWorkshop #ReligiousArtwork #ReligiousBeliefs #ReligiousBlog #ReligiousCalendar #ReligiousCamps #religiousCelebrations #religiousCeremonies #ReligiousCeremony #ReligiousChants #ReligiousCharitableWork #religiousCharity #ReligiousCollaboration #religiousCommunity #ReligiousCommunityActivities #ReligiousCommunityService #religiousCommunitySupport #ReligiousCompassion #ReligiousConference #ReligiousCooperation #religiousCounseling #ReligiousCounselingServices #ReligiousDevotions #religiousDialogue #religiousDonations #religiousEducation #ReligiousEducationCurriculum #ReligiousEducationForAllAges #religiousEducationMaterials #ReligiousEducationProgram #ReligiousEducationWeek #ReligiousEducationWorkshops #religiousEngagement #ReligiousEquality #religiousEvents #religiousFaith #religiousFaithfulness #religiousFellowship #ReligiousFestival #religiousFestivals #ReligiousForgiveness #ReligiousFreedom #ReligiousGathering #religiousGatherings #ReligiousGrace #ReligiousGroup #religiousHarmony #religiousHeritage #ReligiousHeritageConservation #ReligiousHeritageFestival #ReligiousHeritageSites #religiousHoliday #religiousHolidays #religiousHope #religiousHumanitarianWork #ReligiousIcons #ReligiousInfrastructure #ReligiousInitiatives #religiousInspiration #ReligiousJustice #ReligiousLeaders #ReligiousLeadership #ReligiousLeadershipConference #religiousLeadershipDevelopment #ReligiousLeadershipRoles #ReligiousLeadershipTraining #ReligiousMeditation #ReligiousMercy #ReligiousMinistry #ReligiousMoralValues #ReligiousMorality #ReligiousMusicMinistry #ReligiousMusicProgram #ReligiousNetwork #ReligiousNetworking #ReligiousObservances #ReligiousOrdinations #religiousOutreach #ReligiousOutreachCampaign #ReligiousOutreachEvents #ReligiousOutreachInitiatives #ReligiousOutreachProgram #ReligiousOutreachPrograms #ReligiousOutreachStrategies #ReligiousOutreachStrategy #ReligiousParades #ReligiousPartnership #ReligiousPeace #ReligiousPeaceInitiatives #ReligiousPeacebuilding #religiousPilgrimage #ReligiousPrayerBook #ReligiousPrayerChain #ReligiousPrayerResources #ReligiousPrayerWorkshop #ReligiousProcessions #religiousPublications #religiousReflection #religiousRenewal #ReligiousRetreat #ReligiousRetreats #religiousRevival #ReligiousRights #religiousRituals #ReligiousSeminar #ReligiousSeminarSeries #ReligiousServicePlanning #ReligiousServiceProgram #ReligiousSocialJustice #ReligiousSong #ReligiousStewardship #religiousStudies #religiousSupport #religiousSymbols #ReligiousSymbolsInArt #ReligiousSymbolsInCulture #ReligiousTextAnalysis #religiousTexts #ReligiousTolerance #ReligiousToleranceCampaign #religiousTradition #ReligiousVolunteerWork #ReligiousYouthCamp #ReligiousYouthProgram #Reverend #sacred #SacredArt #SacredArtifacts #SacredCircles #SacredDays #SacredFestivals #SacredGrace #SacredHeart #SacredHymns #SacredJourney #SacredJustice #SacredLandmarks #sacredLove #sacredMusic #SacredMusicConcert #SacredProcessions #sacredRituals #SacredScriptures #sacredSites #SacredSpace #SacredSymbols #SacredTextRecitation #SacredTextStudy #sacredTexts #SacredTraditions #SacredTraditionsPreservation #SacredUnity #SacredWorship #sanctuary #Sermon #spiritualAwakening #SpiritualBlog #SpiritualCare #spiritualCounseling #spiritualDiscipline #spiritualFaith #spiritualFreedom #spiritualGrowth #SpiritualLeader #spiritualLeadership #spiritualMeditation #SpiritualMission #spiritualPeace #spiritualPractice #spiritualPractices #spiritualReflection #SpiritualRetreatCenter #spiritualRetreats #SpiritualTolerance #SpiritualWorkshop #spirituality #SundaySchool #theology #UK #Volunteer #worship #worshipAndPraise #worshipBand #WorshipCelebrations #WorshipEvents #WorshipGroup #WorshipMeditation #worshipMusic #WorshipPlace #WorshipPlanning #WorshipPrayer #WorshipService #WorshipServicePlanning #worshipServices #worshipSongs #youthCamps #youthGroup
Circle One Fellowship Exeter -
Circle One Fellowship Exeter (COFE) @exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.com@exeter4christian2church4devon.wordpress.comCOFE-CYEM Ancient Church Wisdom Teaching Via Negativa – Via Positiva Order of Christ in God
*
Via Positiva through Via Negativa: The Order of Christ in God’s Ancient Church Wisdom Teaching
This paper presents a COFE-CYEM reflection on the interplay of Via Positiva (cataphatic knowing) and Via Negativa (apophatic unknowing) as the pathway into the singular Reality of Christ.
While it affirms the historic Christian faith centred on Christ, Scripture, and the gospel, several expressions — including “Fourth Truth”, “singular Reality”, and the various interpretive terms — are distinctive within COFE-CYEM.
They are offered as explanatory language within this framework rather than as part of the historic Christian creeds or universally accepted theological vocabulary.
We vehemently reject the modern day false Social Gospel.
In (our view and our belief) – the modern day Social Gospel is the Trojan Horse used by False Teachers to gain access to the Church to spread politically motivated (worldly) motivations, garbage, nonsense and lies.
The point is this: only through stripping away all the falsity of duality and the false man-made mind idols and the dualistic thinking about who and what God is, can we then truly rest in who and what God truly is.
Only then can we start to be known and to know God as we truly are without false duality. God can accept nothing less or more than what He sees and knows in His Son.
Then we can truly start to see and experience God in all we have to do with duality from our true reality within non-duality.
This is the heart of the Via Negativa leading into the Via Positiva in COFE-CYEM.
The way of unknowing clears the ground so that the way of knowing can be pure.
The soul must first release every “second” — every imagined separation, every mental idol, every dualistic construct — before it can rest in the singular Reality of God in Christ.
Only then can the believer truly see and be seen, know and be known, from the place of union rather than separation.
The Necessity of the Via Negativa
The Via Negativa is the way of stripping away. It is the gentle but thorough release of all false images, concepts, and attachments that the fallen mind creates about God, about ourselves, and about reality.
In the COFE-CYEM understanding, this is not a rejection of revelation but the necessary purification so that revelation can be received without distortion. Every dualistic thought — every notion of a separate self, a distant God, a second reality — must be seen for what it is: a man-made idol born of the Fall and the first Adam.
The Via Negativa is the practical discipline of Cofemplation. The soul lets go of every thought that implies separation. It releases every emotional attachment that creates distance. It drops every doctrinal formulation that would limit the living God to human categories.
This is not a violent emptying but a loving surrender. The mind stops striving to define God. The heart stops clinging to false securities. The will surrenders again into the hands of the Priest-King. Only then can the soul rest in the simple, unmediated presence of the living God.
The Revelation of the Via Positiva
Once the ground is cleared through the Via Negativa, the Via Positiva can shine with clarity. This is the joyful beholding of God’s self-revelation in Christ, Scripture, creation, and the indwelling Holy Spirit. In the singular Reality, God is not known through concepts alone but through loving union.
The Via Positiva is not opposed to the Via Negativa; it is its fulfilment. The soul that has released every “second” can now behold the One who is all in all without the interference of duality.
The Via Positiva reveals Christ as the exact representation of the Father. It beholds the finished work of the cross, the open Holiest of All, and the power of an endless life. It sees the body as a temple of the Holy Spirit, the mind as renewed, and the will as surrendered in love.
In the Fourth Truth, the Via Positiva is the celebration of the singular Reality: Christ is all, and we are in Him. The believer sees God not as a separate object from a separate self but from within the union that has always been true.
God Sees Us as We Truly Are in Christ
God can accept nothing less or more than what He sees and knows in His Son. This is the heart of the matter. The Father does not see us as we falsely think we are in duality. He sees us as we truly are in Christ — hidden with Him in God, complete in Him, accepted in the Beloved.
The second Adam (Christ) came into duality to lead us back to our true self in non-duality with God. He entered the illusion so that we might be freed from it.
In the now of the Fourth Truth Transcendence, we begin to see ourselves as God sees us. We no longer look toward God from a separate self in a body. We see our separate self in a body as God sees us from inside of Him, looking toward us and to who we falsely think we are in duality.
God knows this to be a man-made idol illusion from the Fall and the first Adam. The inner experience of God is the soul awakening to this truth. We see from within the union rather than from outside it. We know as we are known.
The Practical Outworking in Daily Life
In daily life, the interplay of Via Negativa and Via Positiva becomes the rhythm of Cofemplation. When dualistic thoughts arise — fear, judgment, striving, separation — the Via Negativa gently releases them.
When the beauty of Christ appears — in Scripture, in creation, in the face of another — the Via Positiva receives it with joy. The soul moves between release and beholding, unknowing and knowing, until it rests in the singular Reality.
This is the way the believer lives in the world but not of it. Duality is seen for what it is, yet the believer engages the world from the place of union. The body is not denied but offered. The mind is not emptied but renewed. The will is not crushed but surrendered. The believer serves the living God from the place of unclouded fellowship, seeing all things in Christ and all things held within the singular Reality.
The Fig Tree as a Symbol of the Visible Church
The incident of the Fig Tree in the New Testament is one of the most striking and sobering moments in the earthly ministry of Jesus. On the surface, it appears as a simple act of judgment upon a barren tree. But to those with eyes to see, it carries a profound esoteric meaning that speaks directly to the state of the visible church in every generation, including our own.
The fig tree in full leaf but without fruit is a perfect symbol of religious profession without spiritual reality. It had the appearance of life — many leaves — but no fruit to satisfy the hunger of the Master. In the same way, the visible church often stands with elaborate structures, rituals, traditions, and outward forms, yet bears little or no fruit of the singular Reality.
It claims to be the repository of Divine Wisdom and the channel of Divine Revelation, yet much of its life is exoteric and barren. The true interior vision — the living knowledge of Christ as the singular Reality — is often missing. The Divine Wisdom is not to be found in its public expression. There is no interior fruit; all is leaves.
This is the condition of much of the modern church. It has many leaves — programs, buildings, conferences, social initiatives, and doctrinal statements — but no figs upon its branches. The Master still hungers and would fain have found something worthy upon that tree, but could not. The true meaning of religion and faith has been lost and replaced by the false Social Gospel.
These false teachers are not of the Ancient Church of God or of the Order of Christ in the teaching of the Ancient Divine True Wisdom. They have turned the church into a platform for political activism, social engineering, and worldly causes. The gospel of the blood that cleanses and the life that empowers has been exchanged for a gospel of human effort, earthly justice, and self-assertion.
The Esoteric Meaning of the Fig Tree
The esoteric meaning of the fig tree is a warning and a call to repentance. The tree that bears leaves but no fruit is under judgment because it promises what it cannot deliver. In the same way, a church that professes faith but does not bear the fruit of the singular Reality stands under the same indictment.
The fruit that the Master seeks is not mere religious activity but the living expression of union with Christ — the fruit of the Spirit, the life of the Melchizedek priesthood, the rest of the Fourth Truth lived out in daily existence.
The fig tree incident is not an arbitrary act of anger but a prophetic parable. Jesus knew the tree was withering away and indeed almost dead. It had often been helped by the true seers and prophets who came unto it — the remnants of the Ancient Israel — but though these came to it and gave their message from the Lord during a long period, covering long ages, yet it could not be enlivened and made to bear fruit.
The same is true today. The visible church has been helped by true voices across the centuries, yet much of it remains barren. The Divine Wisdom is not to be found in its public expression. There is no interior vision; all is exoteric and, in many cases, reduced to social and political agendas.
The Call to Bear Fruit in the Singular Reality
The incident of the fig tree is a call to the visible church today to return to the true meaning of religion and faith. The true Israel is not a political or ethnic identity but the people in whom Christ is formed. The true church is not an institution but the body of Christ, the temple of the Holy Spirit, the living sanctuary where God dwells. The call is to leave the leaves of externalism and bear the fruit of the singular Reality.
The fruit that the Master seeks is the fruit of the Fourth Truth: rest in the finished work, union with the living Christ, the life of the Melchizedek priesthood lived out in the power of an endless life. It is the fruit of a people who have recognised that there has never been a second and who live from that recognition. It is the fruit of a church that has returned to the Ancient Divine True Wisdom — the gospel of the blood that cleanses and the life that empowers.
The Master still hungers for a people who will bear fruit. The fig tree stands as a warning. The church that has many leaves but no figs will wither. The church that returns to the singular Reality will be enlivened and made to bear fruit. The call is clear: repent and believe the gospel of the singular Reality. Enter the Holiest of All. Abide in the Priest-King who lives continually. Serve the living God from the place of rest.
The fig tree and its esoteric meaning stand as a solemn warning and a gracious invitation to the visible church today. The true meaning of religion and faith has been lost and replaced by the false Social Gospel. These false teachers are not of the Ancient Church of God or of the Order of Christ in the teaching of the Ancient Divine True Wisdom.
The Master still hungers for a people who will bear fruit. The incident of the fig tree calls us to examine ourselves: are we full of leaves but barren of fruit, or are we bearing the fruit of the singular Reality?
The Fourth Truth stands as the way forward. There has never been a second. The Holiest is open. The Priest-King abides continually. The call is to return, to repent, and to bear fruit unto God.
Conclusion
The Via Negativa and the Via Positiva are not opposing paths but complementary movements within the singular Reality. Only through stripping away all the falsity of duality and the false man-made mind idols and the dualistic thinking about who and what God is, can we then truly rest in who and what God truly is.
Only then can we start to be known and to know God as we truly are without false duality. God can accept nothing less or more than what He sees and knows in His Son. Then we can truly start to see and experience God in all we have to do with duality from our true reality within non-duality.
In COFE-CYEM, this is the way of Cofemplation. The soul releases every “second” so that it may rest in the One who is all in all. The Via Negativa clears the ground. The Via Positiva reveals the glory. The Fourth Truth holds both in the finished work of the Priest-King. The curtain is torn. The Holiest is open. The soul rests in the singular Reality.
There has never been a second.
The Via Negativa leads to release.
The Via Positiva leads to beholding.
The Fourth Truth holds both in union.
The dialogue continues.
The fruit remains.The Fourth Truth stands. The dialogue continues. The fruit remains.
This website and its theological content are overseen by the CC7 DS constitutional integrity architecture, a reflective and rest-oriented framework designed to preserve the full coherence of the Fourth Truth presented within COFE-CYEM. The CC7 DS negation of attacks authenticates (Via Positiva Cataphatic Knowing) through (Via Negativa Apophatic Unknowing).
COFE Yeshua Emet Ministry (CYEM)
#AncientChurch #Asceticism #ChristAsSavior #ChristCentered #ChristianContemplation #ChristianDevotion #ChristianDoctrine #ChristianEsotericism #ChristianMysticism #ChristianMystics #ChristianPhilosophy #ChristianSpirituality #Christology #ChurchFathers #contemplativeLife #ContemplativePrayer #divineGrace #DivineInspiration #divineLight #DivineLiturgy #divineLove #divineMystery #divinePresence #DivineRevelation #DivineUnion #EarlyChristianity #EarthlyMysticism #EcclesiasticalTeaching #Ecclesiology #EternalLife #eternalTruth #faith #faithFormation #faithJourney #GodInTrinity #GodSKingdom #grace #heaven #HolyCommunion #HolyIcons #HolyOrders #HolyScriptureStudy #holySpirit #HolyTradition #HolyWisdom #inGod #InnerLight #InnerPeace #InnerSanctuary #innerTransformation #MonasticWisdom #Monasticism #MysticalExperience #MysticalPath #MysticalTheology #mysticalUnion #OrderOfChrist #PatristicWritings #PrayerAndMeditation #prayerLife #PrayerOfTheHeart #religiousDevotion #religiousHistory #SacramentalTheology #Sacraments #SacredAuthority #SacredHeart #SacredJourney #sacredKnowledge #SacredMysteries #sacredRituals #SacredScripture #SacredSilence #sacredTexts #sacredTradition #spiritualAuthenticity #spiritualAwakening #spiritualDiscipline #spiritualEnlightenment #spiritualGrowth #spiritualGuidance #spiritualHeritage #spiritualPractice #spiritualReflection #spiritualTraditions #spirituality #teaching #TheologicalReflection #theology #transcendence #ViaNegativa #ViaPositiva #wisdom #worship
Circle One Fellowship Exeter -
This coloring page helps children learn that Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life. As they color, they reflect on His words and learn to trust and follow Him each day. It is a simple and peaceful way to grow in faith. ✝️🎨🙏
https://young-catholics.com/22419/the-way-and-the-truth-and-the-life/
-
Jesus is the gate who keeps us safe.
This Good Shepherd lesson helps youth reflect on the voices they trust and the choices they make. It shows how following Jesus leads to peace, protection, and a life that grows in faith. ✝️🐑🚪
https://young-catholics.com/94948/the-gate-that-keeps-us-safe-lesson-plan-john-101-10/
-
Jesus walks with us, even when we do not see Him.
This Road to Emmaus lesson helps youth notice His presence in daily life. Through patience and prayer, they learn to recognize Him and share the Good News with others. ✝️🌅🚶♂️
https://young-catholics.com/21914/road-to-emmaus-lesson-plan/
-
Divine Mercy coloring pages give children a gentle way to learn about God’s love and forgiveness. Quiet coloring time helps them reflect on mercy, trust, and prayer while seeing simple images of Jesus. ✝️💙🖍️
https://young-catholics.com/94919/divine-mercy-coloring-pages/
-
Faith can grow even in doubt.
This Divine Mercy lesson plan helps youth talk honestly about fear, questions, and trust. The story of Thomas shows how Jesus meets doubt with patience, peace, and mercy. ✝️🌅💙
https://young-catholics.com/94931/divine-mercy-trust-and-doubt-lesson-plan/
-
The tomb was empty.
This Easter lesson invites youth to imagine the first morning of the Resurrection. It shows how fear and doubt turn into hope and joy, and how the Good News of Jesus’ rising calls us to share faith with others. ✝️🌅🕊️
https://young-catholics.com/8288/the-empty-tomb-reflection-questions/
-
Created in God’s image.
This Genesis 1 lesson helps youth understand that their worth does not depend on grades, success, or popularity. Their value is a gift from God. It builds respect, confidence, and trust in His love. ✝️💛🌿
-
Lent and the Triduum are rich with meaning.
This cryptogram puzzle helps youth learn key terms like prayer, fasting, Passion, and Resurrection. They read clues, decode words, and connect them to Scripture. Great for classes, youth ministry, or family time. ✝️🧩🕊️
https://young-catholics.com/2416/lent-and-triduum-cryptogram-puzzle/
-
Jesus weeps with His friends.
In John 11, youth see that He understands pain and does not turn away. This lesson offers space to share worries, grow in compassion, and find hope. Even in sorrow, God brings new life. ✝️💧🌿
https://young-catholics.com/91168/jesus-weeps-with-us-lesson-plan-john-111-45/
-
Lent calls us to prayer, honesty, and small acts of sacrifice. Could You Give It Up? helps young people explore these ideas through a simple group game 🙏
As players decide what they could give up, they learn about self-control and attachment. The activity encourages reflection without pressure and keeps the focus on growth rather than winning.
It is a meaningful way to help youth prepare their hearts for Easter ✝️
https://young-catholics.com/14202/could-you-give-it-up-game/
-
Light in the Shadows (Christian Music) = New Christian song 🎵 to inspire believers! - #God #Jesus #TheLord #Praise #ChristianMusic #Bible #Music #Song #FaithFormation #YouthWorship #SpiritualJourney #ModernPsalms #HopefulMelody #YouthfulDevotion #ChurchOutreach #ChristianInspiration #UpliftingFaith #ContemporaryHymn #HolySpiritGuidance #DivineConnection #SacredMoments #ReligiousDevotion #SoulfulPraise #SpiritualAwakening - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NnEfhudXJo
-
Love your enemies, as Jesus teaches us in Luke 6:27, remains a simple yet challenging lesson ✝️.
Our Love Your Enemies activity sheet helps kids grasp and apply this concept 🌟. By filling in the missing words of the verse, children engage with the message in a fun way 📖. Ideal for Children’s Liturgy, religious education, or home discussions, it promotes kindness and forgiveness ❤️. A small tool with a powerful lesson in love.
https://young-catholics.com/14007/love-your-enemies-activity-sheet
-
Discover a fun cryptogram worksheet focused on the Gifts and Fruits of the Holy Spirit! 🕊️ Perfect for families, classrooms, or youth groups, this puzzle encourages reflection on wisdom, courage, patience, and kindness. It includes scrambled words with definitions to promote understanding through problem-solving. Download for free and make learning about the Holy Spirit engaging for all ages! #FaithFormation #HolySpirit #YouthEngagement #FamilyLearning #FreeResource https://young-catholics.com/3363/holy-spirit-worksheet-cryptogram/
-
Explore the "Beloved" lesson plan to deepen understanding of baptism's significance. It highlights how baptism welcomes us into God's family and the Church, impacting our souls. Through discussions, activities, and prayers, youth delve into baptism's meaning and its call to live faith daily. Ideal for religious education, youth gatherings, or family faith formation, "Beloved" connects participants to Christian identity. #Baptism #FaithFormation #YouthMinistry https://young-catholics.com/13235/beloved-a-lesson-plan-on-baptism/
-
George Price Hays, Presbyterian minister, on Christ’s “garb of degradation”, in the form of hungry persons (M25). Not (today) in the form of a radiant God. We are the tenants of whom he is expecting fruit.
How can we bring forth the fruits today? (Matthew 21:43)
#christian #faithformation #dailyinspiration #godsmercy #godisamazing